-
Advertisement
Urban planning
Opinion

Hong Kong needs to ensure any underground urban development isn’t another hell on Earth

N. Balakrishnan says the city needs farsighted laws so the profit motive doesn’t rule future underground developments which, with imaginative handling, could be welcome urban sanctuaries for its space-starved populace

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Crowds throng the New Year Flower Market in Victoria Park on January 27, the eve of the Lunar New Year holiday. Victoria Park is among prominent public open spaces around Hong Kong identified as having the potential for underground development. Photo: AFP
N. Balakrishnan
Whenever I hear about expanding urban space below ground, as a study regarding better utilisation of some of our most popular recreational grounds intends to do, I think about a 600-year-old Turkish spa or hamam, located in a basement in one of the oldest city squares of Istanbul.

Emerging from the hamam onto a crowded but spotlessly clean square, I wondered how the square could be kept so clean with just a few small garbage cans, tastefully sculpted in an old Turkish style.

Underground retail space in Hong Kong may lower rents, attract new entrants

The mystery was solved when I saw big trucks pull in at night to yank out the small garbage cans with a big pulley, revealing that the cans had a huge 10-foot square bucket entirely underground.

Advertisement

Garbage thrown into the small cans went through a chute into the big underground box. I realised the Ottomans had long been placing spas and garbage cans below ground in a imaginative way.

Contrast this with the unimaginative stance of Hong Kong bureaucrats in introducing garbage bins with smaller openings, in the vain hope that this will persuade people to produce less waste.
Advertisement
One of Hong Kong’s newly introduced rubbish bins with smaller openings, in Wan Chai last June. Photo: Sam Tsang
One of Hong Kong’s newly introduced rubbish bins with smaller openings, in Wan Chai last June. Photo: Sam Tsang

So, when I hear Hong Kong’s “planners” talk about expanding urban space underground, I worry not so much about the concept itself but the way it will be implemented.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x