Is it morally right for John Tsang to contest the Hong Kong chief executive election?
John Chan says the former financial secretary’s explanation of why he resigned is hard to believe, given that he appears to have been eyeing the top post for years
John Tsang quit finance minister job after row with Chief Executive Leung Chun-ying over budget
Former chief secretary Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor, in stark contrast to Tsang’s wishy-washy stance, had always clearly asserted that she would not run. Her firm denials changed only after Leung said he would not seek a second term. Lam was clear on the point that it would be politically immoral for a serving cabinet member to contest the top post with the incumbent also running.
Watch: Carrie Lam announces candidacy for chief executive
In the US, the last time a former cabinet secretary became a major party’s choice for president was in 1928, when commerce secretary Herbert Hoover won the Republican nomination and went on to become the 31st US president. However, he ran only after sitting president Calvin Coolidge said he would not.
It is political ethics that stops a US cabinet secretary running against a president seeking re-election. This is unlike a cabinet minister under the parliamentary system in the UK or Commonwealth nations, where ministers are elected members of the ruling party or coalition. Cabinet ministers and other ruling party MPs choose their party leader, who becomes the prime minister. They also have the power to depose and replace the incumbent.
Hong Kong’s cabinet of bureau secretaries nominated by the chief executive is similar to the US system. If a financial secretary wishes to run against his chief executive who is bidding for a second term, he must resign as soon as he manifests such an intention – failing to do so would be politically immoral.
Watch: ‘You always agree with your boss’
Tsang was quoted as saying, when questioned on his obvious rift with Leung during the Wang Chau development saga, that: “You always agree with your boss. No question about that.” An explanatory extension could be: “If you do not agree with your boss, you’ve got to leave. No question about that.” More so if he harboured an intention to run against Leung.
John Tsang gives another hint that he may run for Hong Kong’s chief executive
It comes across as a futile attempt to brush aside the lingering doubts over his political morality and integrity concerning the preparations he has been making for the past two years.
John Chan is a practising solicitor and a founding member of the Democratic Party