-
Advertisement
Leung Chun-ying (CY Leung)
Opinion

Legco inquiry into CY’s business dealings must be transparent

The perception that strings are being pulled behind the scenes undermines the process, and harms the integrity of the chief executive and legislature

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Leung confirmed that he made amendments to a document submitted by lawmaker Holden Chow Ho-ding to an inquiry panel to investigate Leung's UGL deal. Photo: David Wong
SCMP Editorial
The controversy surrounding the former business dealings of Leung Chun-ying took a new twist after he sought to alter the scope of a Legislative Council investigation into the matter via a pro-government lawmaker. Inevitably, the move has given rise to the perception of interference. A motion censuring the lawmaker will be tabled by the pan-democrats, who will also further discuss the possibility of an impeachment against the chief executive.
Leung’s so-called interference was exposed after a Legco document submitted by Holden Chow Ho-ding, vice-chairman of the select committee looking into the matter, was found to have contained changes made by the chief executive himself. But their exchanges were not made known to other lawmakers involved in the inquiry. That the behind-the-scenes manoeuvre has raised questions of collusion is to be expected. Chow admitted that he was “politically immature” and was therefore insensitive to the negative perceptions that had arisen. But he denied any intention to cover up the matter, referring to the electronic records of amendments that brought the scandal to light on Monday.
Advertisement

We suppose Chow, of the pro-establishment Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong, did not deliberately leave behind those traces. Chow, a solicitor by profession, sought to legitimise his exchange with Leung by making reference to criminal proceedings, saying it was not unusual for prosecutors to discuss agreed facts with defence lawyers. But the dealings between Chow and Leung clearly went beyond that.

Accompanied by fellow DAB party member Gary Chan Hak-kan (R), lawmaker Holden Chow Ho-ding meets the media at the Legislative Council in Tamar. Chow apologised for
Accompanied by fellow DAB party member Gary Chan Hak-kan (R), lawmaker Holden Chow Ho-ding meets the media at the Legislative Council in Tamar. Chow apologised for
Advertisement

According to records, Leung made 47 changes, some of which involved altering key words and the scope of the inquiry. The select committee is not a judicial proceeding. Lawmakers are playing the combined role of prosecution, judge and jury. They are expected to operate in a fair and independent manner. Such exchanges have happened before, but were always channelled through the Legco Secretariat. Secret contacts will always be seen as inappropriate.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x