Advertisement
Advertisement
In a child’s eyes, life in a subdivided flat is not necessarily miserable. Photo: K.Y. Cheng
Opinion
Opinion
by So Mei Chi
Opinion
by So Mei Chi

For children in Hong Kong’s subdivided flats, small can be both wonderful and heartbreaking

  • What is life like for the 37,000 children and teens who live in partitioned flats? There are real worries, like intergenerational poverty, but also wonder and love. A fuller understanding of life in Hong Kong’s many subdivided flats will inspire empathy and change

At a bookstore reading of my new illustrated book, I began by asking the children present: “Who among you has your own little desk? Who has your own little bookshelf? Who sleeps in your own bed?” Each question summoned a flutter of little hands, which gave a hint of the living standards of the middle-class families who would bring their children to bookstores during the holidays. Then I asked: “If there’s a kid who lives in a little box with his mum and dad, and each person’s share of the space is less than half a parking space, guess what his life is like?”

Children’s reactions are the most direct. One of them opened his arms in a gesture, asking: “How do you live like that?” He looked very, very troubled.

Hong Kong is really a strange place. Seen from the outside, it is dazzling; but in corners where the sun doesn’t reach, there are the most heart-wrenching living conditions. According to the 2016 by-census, nearly 210,000 people live in subdivided flats with a per capita area of 62.4 square feet, and 37,000 of them were children and adolescents under the age of 15.
After a friend at Oxfam asked me to create an illustrated book on subdivided flats, a few of these small figures popped up in my mind – some of the 37,000 young occupants whom I interviewed when I worked for newspapers, wrote about for NGOs, and whom I visited this time for Oxfam.

There’s the “monkey spirit” diagnosed with ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder) who, in a windowless room big enough for a bunk bed, explores all possible angles for climbing and jumping. That little wind-like person makes me, sitting on the edge of the bed, feel dizzy. The mother says she takes the tyke to the park downstairs for eight hours a day to “discharge the battery”, and they wander around until late at night.

There’s the girl going to upper primary school who pulls out a long strip of paper, on which a whole row of black-and-white keys has been meticulously traced. This is how she usually practises the piano, her fingers playing a silent dance. “You must have ambition and motivation, so hard work will pay off!” she says, before laughing playfully. “My mum often says this like a chant.”

There’s the girl of few words who is asked about her wishes. Timidly, she gives the first wish to her mother, the second to her grandfather and grandmother, and the third to her whole family. I say: “Save at least one for yourself, OK?” She laughs but doesn’t. She knows about her mother’s hard work, but she doesn’t know her own heart.

There’s the hospitable single mother who won’t be stopped by the fact that the subdivided flat has no kitchen. She has prepared quite a meal with a rice cooker for this reporter and a social worker, and says with a laugh: “Usually, whether it’s soup, rice or whatever, it’s all thrown into the rice cooker. We rely on it for everything.” Such ingenuity is no use, however, when it comes to her son of upper primary school age. Mother and son have got into fierce fights, and brandished knives at each other. Emotions that boil over like lava have nowhere to go in a small room.

These impressions merged in my mind and became The Incredible Box. Life in a box comes with many worries and many grievances. After all, limits in life don’t just take the form of narrow physical confines – there are also all kinds of lost opportunities, and that curse called intergenerational poverty. Statistics tell us there is a connection that cannot be ignored between adolescents’ backgrounds and their chances of advancing to university; free education is not equal to equal opportunity.

However, in a child’s eyes, life in a subdivided flat is limiting but also magical. For example, a “magic bed” can transform into an arena for a child to spin a top in, a desk for homework, and a dining room where a family eats together happily. The little box holds a lot of dreams and love.

I hope the children who came to the reading saw the creativity, hard work and hope of those who live in subdivided flats

On the day of the reading, Oxfam invited a mother and son to share their experience of living in a subdivided flat, and to compare scenes from the book with their daily routine. What had the most profound effect on me was the mother’s words: “We’ve grown familiar with the neighbours. When school’s out, it’s like a children’s playground. Although it’s a tight squeeze for our family, we love each other dearly.” As I listened, I thought of families where everyone has a separate room and a separate life behind closed doors, and neighbours in private housing who have no contact with one another.

I really hope the children who came to the reading didn’t just hear about the misery of life in a subdivided flat, but also saw the creativity, hard work and hope of those who live in it – planting seeds in their hearts to harvest the power of change.

Before wrapping up, I asked the children: “What can we do?” One child said we should use magic to enlarge the flat. Another didn’t know what to do. I said the children sitting here to listen were already helping: first comes understanding, then comes compassion. Life in subdivided flats is near at hand, and neither grown-ups nor kids have a good excuse for closing their eyes to it.

So Mei Chi is a journalist and writer who takes a special interest in social issues and family dynamics. She is also the author of Strangers at Home, which explores the complicated layers of foreign domestic worker issues in Hong Kong. Writing children’s books is her new endeavour. The Incredible Box is part of an Oxfam book series to raise children's awareness of global and local issues. This article was translated from Chinese

This article appeared in the South China Morning Post print edition as: Both magic and heartbreak in city’s subdivided flats
Post