Advertisement
My Take
Opinion
Alex Lo

My Take | Pan-dems ruin Legco reform for everyone

  • Occupy provocateurs are far from being Hong Kong’s saviours and have nothing to show for their opposition to government electoral moves

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Pro-democracy lawmakers at a question and answer session with Hong Kong’s leader Carrie Lam at the Legislative Council in Tamar. Photo: Sam Tsang
Alex Loin Toronto
I don’t doubt the sincerity and idealism of the nine Occupy provocateurs who are now facing jail. But looking at the righteous nine and their followers, it’s hard not to think of the well-known proverb: the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

The “yellow-ribbon”, or anti-government and anti-mainland, media have been portraying those nine practically as Christlike saints and saviours of Hong Kong. They may well believe that. But there is also another, more prosaic, reason to idolise the last of the Occupy protesters on trial: next year’s Legislative Council elections.

Judging from the recent protest fatigue and the inroads pro-government parties have made in direct elections for the various district councils, the opposition needs a big boost in public support if it is to avoid losing more seats in Legco next year.

Advertisement

It’s a no-brainer to portray the latest prosecution as creeping political repression against which voters must turn out en masse next year to fight. The foreign press and ruling class, especially those in Washington, are more than happy to propagate this narrative as a wedge strategy against China.

But those foreigners can’t vote. The problem is that locally, the opposition is preaching to the choir but not winning over any new converts. Almost half a decade after the 2014 protest movement, many people have reassessed its implications. This was especially so after the Occupy slogans of peace and love turned into the violence and chaos of the Mong Kok riot in 2016. There won’t be much sympathy found next year among the electorate to be translated into votes for the opposition.
Advertisement

The irony is that the pan-democrats have no one else to blame but themselves for being put in this predicament. Let’s recall some recent political history.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x