-
Advertisement
Hong Kong localism, independence
Opinion
Michael Chugani

Opinion | Why Hong Kong independence activist talk at FCC must go on, even if the ideas don’t warrant a megaphone

Michael Chugani says government officials’ overreaction to the planned talk by a Hong Kong National Party co-founder at the Foreign Correspondents’ Club has provoked attention to a lost cause and displays a lack of understanding of local media freedom

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Convenor of the Hong Kong National Party Andy Chan Ho-tin poses for a portrait at Tamar Park. Chan was disqualified from running in the Legislative Council elections in 2016 and the government has recently sought to ban his party. Photo: Winson Wong
What was Beijing thinking? And Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor? And her predecessor Leung Chun-ying? Surely, they know the Foreign Correspondents’ Club would and could never bow to demands to disinvite independence advocate Andy Chan Ho-tin as a guest speaker. If they can’t grasp this, it exposes a troubling ignorance of Hong Kong’s media culture.

Free speech is the heartbeat of the FCC. Asking it to self-censor is like asking it to put a gun to its head. Once it invited Chan, there was no turning back. If it did on Beijing’s order, its very existence as a free speech bastion would be a joke.

Beijing, Lam and Leung need to accept this reality, however unpalatable they find it. Yes, self-censorship exists in sections of the Hong Kong media. But overall media freedom is still intact. It’s a core value the public demands. The media must either swim with this or sink. So must the FCC, which has many local and foreign journalists among its members.

Advertisement

It’s a Hong Kong trait that the more you try to silence a voice, the louder it gets. There really wasn’t any need to silence Chan’s voice because it never resonated with the public. Most Hongkongers shrug off independence as a fantasy. By trying to silence him, Beijing has handed him a megaphone.

Advertisement
Speakers like former British governor Chris Patten, Leung and Lam always guarantee a full house at the FCC. I attended Lam’s talk last year where she spoke her mind on many issues. I remember a Beijing official drawing a packed audience some years ago. Chan’s lunch talk on nationalism next week would have attracted sparse interest had Beijing not tried to ban him. Now it’s full house with guaranteed local and foreign media coverage.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x