-
Advertisement
Carrie Lam policy address 2018
Opinion

Carrie Lam’s policy plan boldly follows the government’s tradition of protecting the status quo

Philip Bowring says the few good ideas proposed by Lam, such as revising tunnel toll fees, should have been put in place long ago. Meanwhile, many of Hong Kong’s perennial problems touching on government and business interests were, again, left untouched

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam attends a question-and-answer session after delivering her policy speech at the Legislative Council. Her policy proposals fall short of truly addressing Hong Kong’s major problems. Photo: AP
Philip Bowring
Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor proclaims that her policy speech shows toughness and disregard for popularity. Well, two cheers for raising central and eastern harbour tunnel tolls, but why has such a necessary move been delayed for so long?

And what is so tough about an impost which affects maybe a quarter of the 8 per cent of Hongkongers who own cars and regularly use the tunnels? What, also, is tough about using taxpayers’ money to subsidise users of the western tunnel, another example of pandering to the motorist minority (of whom I am one) by a civil service over-provided with parking spaces and official cars.

The government also protects the cosy developer-linked monopoly, Autotoll, which collects a high fee for its service through almost all the tollways that are government-owned. Such high fees deter many drivers from using electronic payment, necessitating the use of manned booths and thus raising government collection costs. Electronic tolls should be free and compulsory. 

Advertisement
What is tough about the constant use of subsidies here and there to address issues which should be none of the government’s concern? Building owners are responsible for the safety of their lifts. They should pay, not the public. What is tough about a ban on e-cigarettes other than showing Lam to be the nanny-state personified?

Watch: Highlights of Carrie Lam’s policy address 2018

What is tough about a publicity-seeking announcement to build artificial islands totalling 1,700 hectares which might ease a housing shortage a generation from now, while offering only minor policy initiatives to deal with the problems of today and tomorrow?
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x