Letters | Hong Kong’s brownface perception gap: we need to talk about everyday racism
- Readers discuss the mixed reaction in Hong Kong to TVB’s use of brownface, and highlight discrimination against Southeast Asians in the city
Debate over the TVB series Barrack O’Karma 1968 highlights just how differently segments of Hong Kong society interpret what is racist or discriminatory.
On the one hand, NGOs and migrant worker representatives have criticised the depiction of a Filipino character by a Chinese actress in brownface as based on stereotypes and akin to cultural appropriation. On the other hand, many internet users have been left wondering “what’s the big deal?”, or are lauding the actress’ performance and noting there was no malicious intent behind the portrayal.
While Hong Kong is home to people from all walks of life, this episode is one of many recent and high-profile incidents that confirm just how big of a perception gap there can be between ethnic minority and majority audiences. Hong Kong is a diverse city, but it is still far from inclusive.
But when minority communities experience them day in, day out, they add up, sending a message that one does not belong. Failing to address biases at everyday level – as innocuous as they may seem – allows them to fester, laying fertile ground for more structural forms of racism, overt discrimination and vilification.
The ambiguity of these microaggressions means that conversations are often difficult and nuanced. Because we all have biases, it is likely that we have all been guilty at some point in our lives of accidentally committing one; each of us has work to do on our allyship journey.
The different reactions to this incident show that Asia’s World City stands to benefit from education programmes on diversity and inclusion. We can also broker more opportunities for majority audiences to actively listen to minority voices, validating and respecting their views and focusing on impact rather than intent.
These moments are a learning opportunity we can lean into to build greater consensus and understanding of equality and how to advance it in this vibrant city.
Angie Tse and Victoria Wisniewski Otero, Resolve Foundation
Brownface episode tip of the iceberg of prejudice
As someone who is Filipino and has several relatives who work here as domestic helpers, I not only find this portrayal insulting and racist, but think it does a disservice to Hong Kong’s domestic workers in general, as it reinforces and perpetuates long-held stereotypes.
I’d like to highlight some of the discrimination domestic workers face both systemically and on a daily basis. Domestic workers are often looked down upon in Hong Kong. Most domestic workers are from Southeast Asian countries such as the Philippines and Indonesia. People from these countries tend to be stereotyped as uneducated, clumsy and thieves.
Most people have been civil to my domestic helper aunt. However, I always noticed the way shopkeepers were quick to dismiss and even ignore her when she wanted to buy something, while they attended to other customers right away. I also distinctly remember getting followed around by an employee at a store, presumably because she thought we were going to steal something. Meanwhile, every other customer was left alone.
If a domestic worker is fired, they only have two weeks to find a new employer or risk being fined up to HK$50,000 and sent back to their home country. The government responded by reminding employers of the consequences of violating the Employment Ordinance, but failed to put out guidelines for employers if their domestic helpers contracted Covid-19.
To provide for their families, these women work in a city whose culture and language are completely foreign to them. I can only hope that this incident will make people of all races in Hong Kong more aware of the hardships domestic workers face here.
Bilo Daineset Phyllis Solmiano, Tung Chung