Advertisement
Law
Opinion
Stuart Hargreaves

Opinion | Hong Kong’s laws need to evolve as protests enter the digital realm

  • As the anti-extradition movement has shown, protests play out in the digital arena too, raising questions about whether the law should treat them the same as in the physical world. How we protect our virtual rights will be most instructive

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Extradition bill demonstrators take a break outside the Department of Justice in Hong Kong last month. The use of encrypted messaging, peer-to-peer communication technology, doxing and cyber attacks have shown that the protest is also very much in the digital realm. Photo: Sam Tsang
The extradition bill protests in Hong Kong have provided no shortage of remarkable visuals that will remain etched in our collective memory. Less visibly, but no less importantly, the conflict that has roiled the city is also playing out in the digital realm.
Protesters made judicious use of encrypted messaging apps to communicate not only with one another, but also with the media. They also used local peer-to-peer communication technology such as Apple’s Airdrop to anonymously send messages and plans to those in their immediate vicinity, entirely avoiding reliance on any communication infrastructure that could possibly be monitored.
Knowledge of how to use technology to avoid detection also extended to when not to use it — protesters stopped using Octopus cards and turned to single-use MTR tickets instead, to leave no digital trail. A minority also chose to use digital tools in a much more aggressive fashion. It was reported that 600 police officers had been “doxxed”, meaning their personal information was spread online. The police issued take-down requests to the websites to scrub the internet of the leaked personal details.
Advertisement
Those in favour of the bill (or opposed to the protests) also made use of the digital realm to advance their cause. A large distributed denial of service (DDoS) attack on Telegram, the encrypted messaging app used by protesters, was launched on June 12 at the same time the protests began.

Though no one took responsibility for the attack, Telegram’s chief executive officer said the size of the attack was consistent with the resources of a state actor and came primarily from IP addresses located in mainland China.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x