Advertisement

Macroscope | Central banks like the Fed and the ECB can’t save the global economy when governments refuse to play their part

  • Fed and ECB actions after the 2008 crisis have been crucial, but they have reached the limits of what they can achieve
  • If governments like Germany won’t stimulate and Italy won’t reform, it’s unreasonable to expect more from central banks

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Italian Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte (centre) chats to other politicians after his speech at the Senate in Rome on August 20. Without deep structural reforms, Italy looks certain to remain “the sick man of Europe”. Photo: EPA-EFE

The US Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank, the world’s two most influential central banks, are in a bind. As a mood of gloom envelops the global economy, both institutions have been under intense pressure from markets to unleash further stimulus measures.

Advertisement

Yet, while investors expect additional easing, they have never been more sceptical about the ability of central banks to stabilise markets and stimulate growth.

While both central banks are loath to precipitate a sharp sell-off by failing to meet investors’ expectations, the markets, and indeed central bankers themselves, doubt the efficacy of monetary policy, given that the threats and impediments to global growth are beyond central banks’ control.

To be sure, there is a strong case for more stimulus, especially in the euro zone, where the core inflation rate – which strips out volatile food and energy prices – has dropped to less than half the ECB’s 2 per cent target. Germany, Europe’s largest economy, is on the brink of recession, while manufacturing activity in the bloc as a whole has contracted for the past seven months, survey data from IHS Markit shows.
European Central Bank President Mario Draghi attends a news conference at the ECB headquarters in Frankfurt on March 7. Photo: Reuters
European Central Bank President Mario Draghi attends a news conference at the ECB headquarters in Frankfurt on March 7. Photo: Reuters
Advertisement

Even in America, whose economy is still relatively buoyant, growth has slowed markedly as the trade war has intensified. Manufacturing output shrank last month for the first time since 2016, while a gauge of consumer sentiment suffered its sharpest fall since 2012.

Advertisement