Advertisement

Opinion | The political violence won’t end as long as Hong Kong and Beijing officials keep adding fuel to the fire

  • Across the world, the roots of political violence can be traced to unresolved grievances, a weak sense of belonging and an unresponsive government
  • To reduce the tensions in Hong Kong, officials should start listening to people’s concerns, and find new ways to redress wrongs

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Illustration: Craig Stephens
On July 21 in Yuen Long, more than 100 armed men in white T-shirts indiscriminately attacked and injured at least 45 people. Then, on October 13 in Mong Kok, a home-made bomb was remotely detonated. These acts of political violence against civilians demand that we understand their causes in order to prevent them.

Like furious, wronged children whose families have failed them, violent political actors strike out at society. Facing political violence on both sides, Hong Kong can either wrong more people to fuel it further or redress wrongs to reduce tensions.

Political violence is more likely to (a) occur in societies with collectivist cultures, declining economies, societal changes or unresponsive governments – like Hong Kong; and (b) be the work of individuals with unresolved grievances, a weaker sense of belonging, or a superior education or skills.

Advertisement
Collectivist cultures that support personal sacrifices for the sake of the group, like in Afghanistan, Sri Lanka and Yemen, have produced many suicide bombers, whereas individualistic cultures like Australia have not.

People who perceive their opportunities for employment as being worse than their parents’ are often pessimistic, aggrieved and more prone to political violence. This is seen in countries like Egypt, Somalia and Syria. In contrast, poor people with better job prospects are optimistic and rarely participate in political violence – take Costa Rica as an example.

Advertisement
Societal changes threaten people who prefer the status quo, so they might take extreme steps to maintain it. For example, the emergence of a secular society drove religious zealots – al-Qaeda, Islamic State – to political violence. In Hong Kong, for many, the proposed easing of renditions to China was a reminder of the abduction of five booksellers to the mainland in 2015, provoking fear of political prosecution and the weaker legal protection in mainland China.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x