Advertisement
Coronavirus pandemic
ChinaPolitics
Chi Wang

Opinion | The ‘sick man of Asia’ headline is indefensible. But China’s expulsion of reporters is the wrong answer

  • The Cold War created a void filled by propaganda and cultural misunderstanding for an entire generation in the US and China. The best way to prevent misunderstanding today is to improve education on both sides rather than kick out reporters

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Wall Street Journal reporters Philip Wen (left) and Josh Chin leave China via Beijing Capital Airport on February 24, after the row over the newspaper’s “Sick Man of Asia” headline. Photo: AFP
The coronavirus epidemic has become the top news story around the world. In the United States, paranoia is spreading more rapidly than Covid-19. While fear of the unknown is natural, it seems that the hysteria in the US goes beyond this and is rooted in xenophobia.
Commentary on the coronavirus crisis has been focused more on the fact that the outbreak started in China than on the actual impact of the outbreak on innocent Chinese people. It is in this context that The Wall Street Journal’s “Sick Man of Asia” headline has fuelled such a backlash in both China and the Chinese-American community.

I first heard the epithet in an entirely different time, and an entirely different context. I was a junior school student in Beijing in the 1930s, when China was entering the Olympic Games for the first time. The first Chinese Olympian, Liu Changchun, competed in Los Angeles in 1932, but his exhaustion from the long journey affected his performance and kept him off the podium. Nonetheless, we were proud he had represented China.

Advertisement

My teachers encouraged my peers and me to play sports and commit ourselves to physical fitness, so China could take part in the Olympics and would no longer be seen as the “sick man of east Asia”. Inspired, I committed to learning soccer, ice skating, running and swimming. The particular history of the epithet seems to have been forgotten, but some 80 years later, the phrase itself has not.

It has been a month since the WSJ ran an opinion piece with the now notorious headline: “China is the Real Sick Man of Asia”. At first, there was an outrage among the Chinese-American community, but it has since ballooned to involve the Chinese Foreign Ministry, the US State Department and free speech advocates.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x