Advertisement
HSBC
Opinion
SCMP Editorial
SCMP Editorial

Opinion | HSBC finds itself caught between a rock and hard place

  • With dividends cancelled because of an order by British regulators, the bank – having abandoned Hong Kong in 1993 – now has few friends here even if it wants to return

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
People walk past the HSBC logo in Central. The bank followed the call from the Prudential Regulation Authority, a British regulator, to cancel dividends until at least the fourth quarter in the light of the coronavirus pandemic. Photo: Sam Tsang
SCMP Editorial

HSBC chairman Mark Tucker is probably not a punk rock fan but he may find special resonance in this 1980s classic from The Clash: “Should I stay or should I go now? If I go, there will be trouble. And if I stay it will be double.”

Ever since the banking giant relocated its global headquarters to London in 1993, there have been periodic talks about returning to its historical home in Hong Kong. Last time, the rumours were triggered by the turmoil of Brexit. This time, it is the shock decision to cancel dividend payments, possibly until the fourth quarter this year, after being told to do so by British regulators. This has surprised and outraged investors in equal measure, especially its legions of faithful retail shareholders in the city, many of whom depend on the quarterly payments for income.
The decision promptly sent its shares down by 14 per cent last week, wiping out HK$123 billion in market capitalisation. Fellow British bank and Hong Kong note issuer Standard Chartered suffered similarly on being instructed to do the same by the British Prudential Regulation Authority – a regulator far away from the banks’ biggest market in Hong Kong.
Advertisement

The shock is understandable. HSBC has faithfully paid investors continuously since 1946, a proud tradition that has also been one of its main attractions to local conservative retail investors despite its lacklustre stock performance over the past decade.

The bank makes most of its profits in Hong Kong and the rest of Asia, and is pivoting its business on China’s growth. Unsurprisingly, many investors and reportedly even some bank insiders have raised the issue of homecoming again.

Advertisement

HSBC is well capitalised and could well have paid the dividends. But British authorities prefer to push banks to keep their capital during the coronavirus pandemic and economic downturns so as to lend to small businesses and homeowners, as well as waiving banking fees to low-income customers. Hurting investors and shareholders far away was not a significant consideration.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x