Advertisement
Hong Kong property
Opinion
SCMP Editorial

Editorial | Finding the right price for Kai Tak vision

  • While the government does not want to send the wrong signal about its commitment to the future of the harbourfront site, it risks delaying the whole project by holding out for what it thinks the land is worth

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Residential buildings under construction at the site of Hong Kong’s former airport at Kai Tak. Photo: Martin Chan
The transformation of a 320-hectare single-use harbourfront site into a multi-use residential, commercial and sporting hub has become a complex development challenge. The old Kai Tak airport site may have ceased to be our international gateway long ago, but it still reflects sentiment about the city’s prospects. An example is the Lands Department’s withdrawal from sale last week of a large commercial plot because bids failed to meet expectations.
Despite the location, developers have curbed their appetite for such prime sites amid a recession in the aftermath of the coronavirus crisis, on top of social unrest and the US-China trade war. As a result officials have to reconcile their vision with negative perceptions about the city’s commercial market outlook. The vision is of a vibrant, people-oriented residential and commercial community by the harbour, including a network of public parks and gardens. In a show of faith in the project, the government has chosen to take the plot back rather than risk it being undervalued. However, several market-watchers have said the withdrawal shows the government is out of touch with market mood and prices, and suggested it should think outside the box of its current model of land tender to award land based on more criteria such as the environment and sustainability.

The withdrawal also indirectly raises the issue of government intervention in the free market. Hong Kong remains a market economy, but there has been a lot of debate about the role of government since the financial tsunami and the inflation in asset prices driven by fiscal stimulus. Ultimately it led to public acceptance of the need for government measures to cool soaring property prices. That said, the way back to economic and job growth still lies in infrastructure and building projects in which the private sector leads and the government facilitates, as the saying goes.

Advertisement

The overall Kai Tak vision of commercial and residential development, including a sporting complex, remains worthy of support. Understandably the government does not want to send the wrong signal about its commitment to the vision. The price it risks paying in the short term by holding out for what it thinks the land is worth is a delay to the whole project.

Help us understand what you are interested in so that we can improve SCMP and provide a better experience for you. We would like to invite you to take this five-minute survey on how you engage with SCMP and the news.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x