Advertisement
The View | World economic divide blurs as US, Europe step up state aid and China optimises market efficiency
- Western states are ‘nationalising’ wages and revisiting state capitalism while China intensifies its market reforms, offering no wage subsidies or big bailouts – as Covid-19 brings countries closer together on the ideological spectrum
Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP

With all the talk on decoupling and reshoring, is the globalised world fragmenting? Despite the rhetoric, we may be witnessing a convergence of economic policies in responding to Covid-19. While nations may be distancing from one another, their policy practices may be getting closer on the ideological spectrum.
Initially, the world watched the Wuhan lockdown with a mixture of revulsion and amazement. But after their cavalier and tardy responses, missing the window in which they could have adopted the South Korean approach of testing and tracing, Italy and Spain had no choice but to adopt the “Chinese model” of lockdown.
In economic responses to mitigate the pain on livelihoods, some Western economies have been decidedly “socialistic”. Through wage subsidies, payroll has been “nationalised” in some European countries to save jobs. Even the United States has resorted to universal basic income, and with Trump’s signature on the cheques.
Advertisement
In contrast, China has offered modest support beyond its limited unemployment safety net. China’s many migrant workers who do not have work contracts or contribute to the unemployment insurance scheme are essentially self-insured. Beyond drawing on their savings, those who still have land in their home villages can live on the land. Such is the reality of a developing country at a self-professed early stage of socialism.

04:15
Chinese farmers see livelihoods threatened by coronavirus pandemic and related economic slump
Chinese farmers see livelihoods threatened by coronavirus pandemic and related economic slump
China has not spent too much on alleviating short-term hardships for what may be long-term structural adjustment problems. China’s government subsidies are more for worker retraining than mere worker retention. Fully recognising the capitalistic logic of creative destruction, the pandemic being the latest impetus, China has saved its bullets for supporting enterprises amid the downturn.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x
