-
Advertisement
Cultural Revolution
Opinion
SCMP Editorial

Editorial | Clarity welcome on Cultural Revolution

  • New references in latest China student textbook seek to address apparent confusion and misinterpretation prompted by previous instances

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A propaganda squad of Red Guards, high school and university students, brandishing the copies of Chairman Mao Zedong's ‘Little Red Book’, staging a rally in September 1966. Photo: AFP
Facing resistance against its global rise and international pressure over Hong Kong, Xinjiang and Taiwan, China has enough external troubles without another internal debate on the nature of the Cultural Revolution. But new references in a student textbook have prompted one. It can be a positive and necessary experience if it addresses apparent confusion and misinterpretation prompted by previous editions.
In that respect the current high school first-year history textbook, used to teach 16-year-olds, is to be welcomed. Just two years ago a middle-school textbook sparked criticism for whitewashing the turbulent time in describing it as a “detour”, which was seen to reflect efforts by ultra-leftists to gloss over the tragic decade of upheaval from 1966 during which an estimated 1.7 million people died.

Last year state news agency Xinhua attempted to address the issue in an article that argued the “Cultural Revolution was not and could not be a revolutionary or societal advancement by any definition”, an assertion echoed in last year’s textbook.

Advertisement

Now, more comprehensively and explicitly, the current history textbook says the Cultural Revolution was “provoked by [party] leaders erroneously, and used by an anti-revolutionary syndicate” – a reference to ultra-leftists. It describes the era as one of “civil unrest that brought serious disaster to the country and the people”.

It also retains a reference from last year that says it was “not a revolution or social progress in any sense”. This is a rebuttal of some who have tried to characterise the era as one of progress, a trend that began after President Xi Jinping said in 2013 that former paramount leader Deng Xiaoping’s reformist policies could not negate the preceding 30 years of achievements.

Advertisement

In 1981, Deng and fellow party leader Hu Yaobang tried to draw a line under the era with a party resolution that called the Cultural Revolution a “gross error” and said Mao Zedong had made mistakes.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x