Advertisement
US-China relations
Opinion
Chris Fenton

Mulan case study: How China and the US can prevent tensions from boiling over

  • China should stop retaliating when Americans exercise free speech in America – without that safety valve, bilateral pressures and controversies can only build up
  • In Mulan’s case, should Disney apologise to Americans and Beijing acknowledge its right to do so, without threatening its business in China, tensions would decrease

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
A scene from Disney film Mulan. The massive economic value of bilateral commercial and cultural exchange has developed into a costly silence among Americans and American companies. Photo: Disney via AP

In the broadest sense, I see the US-China relationship like a mobile phone connection to a cell tower. In a perfect scenario, there are five bars of service connecting the two – five diplomatic forces that either connect the two nations or distance them: politics, national security, human rights, culture and commerce.

I strongly believe the United States and China can continue their collaborative yet competitive relationship, while also sharing little common ground on the three diplomatic forces of politics, national security and human rights. Why? Because of the other two forces – culture and commerce.

Those forces provide a real chance for the US and China to connect and bond. There is much proof already, whether with LeBron James, Nike and the NBA on one hand, or Tom Cruise, Disney and Hollywood on the other. In forging the bilateral exchange of culture and commerce, there will always be connective tissue between the superpowers.
Advertisement

But if that stops, the final two bars of mobile service go blank. The connection between phone and tower ends. The world’s two superpowers stop communicating.

We cannot go there. Our two countries must keep that from happening. We must avoid a world where our two nations are engaged in a cold war.

04:12

Are Xi Jinping’s China and Donald Trump’s US destined for armed conflict?

Are Xi Jinping’s China and Donald Trump’s US destined for armed conflict?

So, here is an idea focused on the disputed area of human rights. China should simply let Americans voice their opinions in America without the threat of market retaliation. China’s recognition of Americans’ free speech rights would surely go a long way to easing bilateral pressures.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x