-
Advertisement
My Take
Opinion
Alex Lo

My Take | In Hong Kong, reality is either ‘yellow’ or ‘blue’

  • Such perceptual distortions happen in every polarised society as new overseas research shows the deeper the division, the more sharply people’s perceptions bifurcate; and sharing common ground becomes increasingly unlikely

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
16
A man relaxes on a Kowloon promenade that runs along Victoria Harbour, with the skyline of Hong Kong Island in the background on March 18, 2021. (Photo by Anthony WALLACE / AFP)

If, like me, you spend a lot of time scanning local chat groups, online platforms and media outlets self-identified as “yellow” (anti-China/government) or “blue” (pro-China/government), one thing you notice is that they almost always comment on the same news topics, but inevitably arrive at opposite or opposing conclusions.

It’s not only that their views on society, government and country are highly polarised along fairly predictable lines, but also their very perceptions of the same factual reality are predetermined. Consider the following hot topics and how the two camps have been talking about them.

Hongkongers holding BN (O) passports and moving to Britain are either political refugees and exiles, or paranoid and delusional fools suffering from a persecution complex. The British BN (O) scheme allowing many Hong Kong people a path to citizenship is either a generous offer to help save as many Hongkongers as possible from Chinese totalitarianism or a British scam to steal the capital and talent one last time from a former colony.
Advertisement
The national security law and electoral overhaul imposed by the central government is either the best thing that has happened to Hong Kong since the 1997 return of sovereignty to China or the Chinese takeover of the city by stripping it of all valuable and essential qualities. They are either destroying “one country, two systems” or saving it. It’s either the rebirth of Hong Kong after a long period of societal turmoil as it is integrated into the economic engine of the Greater Bay Area, or the death of the city as we know it.

02:34

China’s top legislative body passes sweeping Hong Kong electoral reforms

China’s top legislative body passes sweeping Hong Kong electoral reforms

So-called peaceful pro-democracy protesters are all rioters and traitors. So-called patriots are all sycophants and opportunists. The one group sells out China, the other sells out Hong Kong. The West is either our saviour or our corruptor.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x