Advertisement
Coronavirus vaccine
Opinion
Alice Wu

Opinion | Can segregation rules at bars, restaurants really help raise Hong Kong vaccination rate?

  • With its ‘vaccine bubble’, the government has offloaded the responsibility to boost vaccine uptake onto struggling bars and restaurants
  • The complex arrangement also disregards those who have recovered from Covid-19, or have genuine reasons not to take the vaccine

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
6
A bar reopens in Tsim Sha Tsui on April 29. Bars and nightclubs are conditionally allowed to reopen at half capacity till 2am if all staff and customers receive at least one vaccine dose. Photo: K.Y. Cheng
Since February, Israel has deployed a “green pass” system that allows those who have been vaccinated or who have recovered from the coronavirus to regain access to hotels, restaurants, gyms, cinemas and cultural and sporting events. In the case of those under 16, they will be allowed the same access if they test negative for Covid-19.

Israel is reopening because it has one of the world’s most successful vaccine roll-outs, with 60 per cent of the population having received at least one dose, and 56 per cent fully vaccinated.

Britain has been doing exceptionally well in the vaccination department as well, in stark contrast to the headlines about its shocking mismanagement of the coronavirus response last year. According to the latest figures, 51 per cent of Britons have received at least one dose of vaccine. However, while the British government is set to require vaccine passports for international travel, it has dropped plans to require Covid-19 status certificates for entry to pubs and restaurants domestically.
Advertisement

Domestic or international vaccine passports are being rolled out, or considered, in various countries. Certainly, these programmes provide an incentive for people to get the jab. The thinking behind these programmes is that restrictions that limit freedoms and social activities should be tailored to verifiable risk.

There’s nothing controversial here, but how this thinking is put into practice can raise concerns.

02:13

Phuket gets Thailand’s first Covid jabs as resort island prepares to reopen to foreign tourists

Phuket gets Thailand’s first Covid jabs as resort island prepares to reopen to foreign tourists

Given the different cultural, social and political contexts that governments have to navigate, there really is no gold standard, though all must be mindful of the danger of granting privileges on the basis of health and fitness.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x