Advertisement
US-China relations
Opinion
Winston Mok

The View | How US, China can recover and thrive by being more like each other

  • Despite the abundance of heated rhetoric, the competition between the US and China is not between two political and economic systems
  • The challenges each faces in economic development are similar, as are the levers each has at their disposal to improve the lives of their citizens

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
7
The Chinese and American flags fly on a lamp post along Pennsylvania Avenue near the US Capitol in Washington during then president Hu Jintao’s state visit on January 18, 2011. Photo: Reuters
In marshalling allies against China and Russia, US President Joe Biden has used the term “market democracies” while resorting to non-market industrial policies in the rivalry against authoritarian state capitalism. Ironically, the key impediment against US success in such a race is the partisan politics within American democracy.
In the polarised politics of the United States, China the bogeyman has become the single unifying theme. The US Senate last month passed the Innovation and Competition Act, among the most expansive pieces of industrial policy legislation in US history.

In fact, the US has had a long and successful tradition of industrial policies. Initiated by Alexander Hamilton, the first US treasury secretary, industrial policies in various guises have played an important role in America’s rise and expansion. After World War II, US government support continued in various space, defence and biotechnology-related initiatives, continuing even after Ronald Reagan’s neoliberal presidency.

Advertisement
The US has been a most successful development state. Instead of emulating China or other East Asian economies, the US is arguably reviving its past. However, there is no guarantee that reviving industrial policies will be successful today.

State investments can be captured by special interests. In the Innovation and Competition Act, which is still subject to revisions in Congress, much of the funding originally slated for emerging technologies has been diverted away to parochial projects by pork barrel politics.

A poorly implemented industrial policy could make the US economy less efficient and less resilient. Still, Biden can do much good, in the spirit of Franklin D. Roosevelt, by turning away from neoliberalism and towards a more active state.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x