Advertisement
Technology
Opinion
Philippe Aghion
Aymann Mhammedi
Philippe AghionandAymann Mhammedi

Opinion | Capitalism rethink: innovation needn’t come at the expense of worker protection

  • It is possible to encourage innovation and still protect workers from creative destruction. The answer lies in beefed-up competition policy and a Danish-style ‘flexicurity’ system

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
6
A man walks by a “Help Wanted” sign in Queens, New York, on June 4. The US economy continues to add jobs every month but millions of Americans remain unemployed. Photo: AFP

The Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted major weaknesses in both the US and European capitalism models. In the United States, the crisis has shown the limits of an economic system that fails to protect individuals from the effects of creative destruction and the social consequences of macroeconomic shock.

In Europe, it has revealed the insufficient dynamism of its innovation ecosystem – particularly in biotech. For all the harm caused, the pandemic is also a call to rethink capitalism.

We do not regard the US model’s lack of protection and inclusiveness as the price of greater innovation. Nor do we think Europe’s lack of innovation a natural consequence of greater inclusion and social protection.

Advertisement

So, besides calling for greater education, we advocate two policies that should stimulate innovation-based growth and make it more inclusive and/or protective: beefed-up competition policy, and a Danish-style “flexicurity” system.

So why has the innovative US economy, which spearheaded the information technology revolution, seen declining productivity growth over the past two decades? Two possible explanations emphasise a competition problem.

03:14

Is the US economy an oligarchy?

Is the US economy an oligarchy?

Thomas Philippon argued in The Great Reversal that the main reason was the weakening of antitrust policies, which led to greater concentration in many sectors and eroded dynamism, especially company creation.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x