-
Advertisement
My Take
Opinion
Alex Lo

My Take | No surprise scholar from hostile NGO denied visa

  • Hundreds of Chinese students and scholars have had their visa applications rejected in the United States, but it seems to matter more if a local university can’t hire an American human rights specialist

Reading Time:2 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
37
Dr Ryan Thoreson. Photo: Twitter

One visa rejection is news in Hong Kong; hundreds of such rejections are a statistic in the United States.

Ryan Thoreson, a US legal scholar, made international news when the Immigration Department denied him a work visa to take up a full-time post to teach human rights and sexual minority rights at the University of Hong Kong.

No official explanation was given, but it seems fairly obvious. He works for Human Rights Watch (HRW), an American NGO which made no bones about supporting the highly destructive riots and protests in 2019, and has gone out of its way to pick fights with the city’s government. I leave aside its constant stream of reports over the years criticising China’s human rights, which I haven’t read.

Advertisement
In January 2020, Kenneth Roth, HRW’s executive director and Thoreson’s boss, decided to release its “World Report 2020” in the city, which carried an essay on the Chinese government’s “assault” on the international human rights system. That was a most sensitive time, when riots were still happening, though dying down.
He wasn’t surprised that he was denied entry to Hong Kong. As expected, it created an international newsworthy incident generating plenty of publicity for his report. Since then, Roth’s group has criticised every major political development in the city.
Advertisement

The Immigration Department would really have to be masochistic to let one of Roth’s associates take up a tenure-track job at the city’s most prestigious university. Perhaps Thoreson could recruit his students to work as interns for HRW and advocate for transsexual rights. That might justify his employment and productivity in Hong Kong, but I can appreciate the department might think differently.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x