Advertisement
US-China relations
Opinion
Zhou Xin

Opinion | US efforts to strip China of its ‘developing nation’ tag reflect an increasingly polarised world

  • The US House’s unanimous vote on the PRC Is Not a Developing Country Act is just the latest on a long list of quarrels between Beijing and Washington
  • The facts on the ground are that China is not yet a developed country, but facts probably won’t matter to angry and hostile US politicians

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
18
A villager goes uphill to get water in Nongyong village, southern China’s Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region. Photo: Xinhua

The unanimous vote by the US House of Representatives to deprive China of its status as a “developing country” is set to open a new diplomatic row between Washington and Beijing, dealing another blow to an already-fragile global governance system.

It is not the first time that the two countries have quarrelled over the economic status of China. The Chinese government, for instance, tried for about a decade to persuade the US and EU, two of its largest trading partners, to treat China as a market economy – a move that would help Chinese exporters in anti-dumping cases and give Beijing a nominal thumbs up to its economic liberalisation efforts.

To Beijing’s frustration, the US and EU never granted China’s wish. Beijing eventually threw in the towel and halted its case at the World Trade Organization in 2019, when China’s trade war with the US under the Trump administration became the more urgent priority.
Fighter jets are seen over the US Capitol building in Washington. Photo: AFP
Fighter jets are seen over the US Capitol building in Washington. Photo: AFP

The “market economy” label affects how fair prices are calculated in anti-dumping cases, but the “developing country” tag is much more important to China due to its political and economic implications. The latter represents the core of the country’s self-positioning since it began to officially join international bodies in the 1970s.

Advertisement

For the past half-century or so, the “developing country” label has become the default basis on which China participates in international organisations and strikes agreements ranging from trade to climate change.

When dealing with Washington, Beijing has now and again returned to the line that the US is the world’s largest developed economy, while China is the largest developing economy.

Advertisement

The latest efforts by US politicians to revoke China’s “developing country” status will be seen by Beijing as another trick by Washington to contain and suppress the nation’s development. The full bipartisan support towards the PRC Is Not a Developing Country Act only shows the depth of the anger and hostility against China.

This aerial photo shows farmers picking tea leaves at in Yongrong township, in southwest China’s Chongqing. Photo: Xinhua
This aerial photo shows farmers picking tea leaves at in Yongrong township, in southwest China’s Chongqing. Photo: Xinhua
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x