Advertisement
My Take
Opinion
Alex Lo

My Take | 2 letters that help explain the catastrophe in Ukraine, Europe and the world today

  • In America, there have been deep foreign policy thinkers, and warmongers and propagandists; too bad most in the first group are now dead

Reading Time:5 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
49
Ukrainian service members ride a BMP-1 infantry fighting vehicle, amid Russia’s attack on Ukraine, near the front line in the newly liberated village Neskuchne in Donetsk region, Ukraine. Photo: Reuters

“Not worried about a nuclear holocaust? You should be.” – Christopher Nolan, director of Oppenheimer the movie

Two open letters, separated by almost exactly 26 years, landed in my inbox recently.

It’s rare to have a genuine teachable moment in global politics, recent history and intellectual responsibility. But if you read both of them, and compare and contrast them, and then reach your own independent conclusions, I believe you will have gained much deeper insights into the war in Ukraine, Russian aggression, Nato expansion, the threat of nuclear war, and generally, the dangerous world we live in today.

Advertisement

If I could have my way, I would have considered my job done today by linking the two letters online and pointing out briefly their relevance for readers. That would have been my contribution, however infinitesimal, to world peace and understanding. Alas, I only get paid if I produce a column. So, apologies for my own propaganda and biases in the following. I recommend you to just skip them, and go straight to those two letters. And yes, please read them both.

Forty-six warmongers and propagandists

Advertisement
The publication early this month of an open letter signed by 46 individuals billed as “foreign policy experts” in the United States offers what may be called the maximalist position of the West on the Ukraine crisis. Many have impressive titles as former senior officials in the US State Department and the Pentagon. A few are famous, such as the political theorist Francis Fukuyama. But, as some critics have pointed out, almost half of them have commercial links or interests with the US weapons industry or with militant think tanks financed by the industry. Their connections were not disclosed. If there is a single group that unquestionably benefits from the war, it’s the US military-spying industrial complex.
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x