Advertisement
My Take
Opinion
Josephine Ma

My Take | Panic over, but the health risks of Covid-19 are still being debated

  • No consensus from scientists on the dangers of reinfection or who should get boosted, but they agree older people more at risk
  • The virus continues to pose a risk to the elderly and immunocompromised, and it would be unwise to ignore its existence

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
While mask and vaccine mandates are no longer justifiable, preventative measures should still be taken to prevent vulnerable people, especially the elderly, from Covid-19 reinfections. Photo: Xinhua
With the world opened up and economic activities resumed, many people have left the pandemic completely behind. But scientists are continuing to debate whether reinfection with Covid-19 poses health risks.

Frequently cited in the discussion is a study by researchers from Washington University in St Louis, Missouri, that concluded reinfections increased the risks of mortality, hospitalisation, the development of lung and heart issues, as well as brain fog and other problems.

The study, published late last year in the peer-reviewed journal Nature Medicine, was based on the data of nearly 41,000 people who suffered reinfection, collected from US Department and Veterans Affairs healthcare centres.

Advertisement

But some scientists have disputed the findings, arguing that the data was largely based on elderly, white males, and that the researchers did not study their underlying health conditions.

While it is obvious that previous infection or vaccination cannot prevent reinfection, there is so far no consensus among the scientific community about the potential health risks of further infections.

Advertisement

One reason the question is so hard to answer is that there are two forces at work when reinfection occurs, and individuals can respond very differently depending on their health circumstances.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x