Advertisement
Renewable energy
Opinion
Tomos Harrison
Evan Gach
Tomos HarrisonandEvan Gach

Eye on Asia | By ditching coal for biomass, Japan and South Korea are embracing false hope of a zero-carbon future

  • Burning wood pellets to generate power is often not carbon neutral and can be more polluting than coal
  • By funding biomass instead of wind and solar, governments will undermine their net zero goals, waste taxpayer’s money and add to deforestation

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
5
COP26 activists in Glasgow dressed as Pikachu call for Japan to stop using coal-fired power on November 4. Adopting biomass will hurt Japan’s coal phase-out. Photo: Kyodo
The assumption that burning biomass can replace or mitigate coal’s negative effects is not just questionable science, it is dangerously undermining coal phase-out plans in Japan and South Korea.

Last year, my colleagues and I [Tomos] took a close look at Britain’s biggest greenhouse gas emitter. It’s not a coal plant – at least not any more, really.

Since 2012, Drax Group has been transitioning out of coal; its last coal-fired plant is expected to shut down later this year. Drax is now the biggest biomass-based electricity producer in Europe – mostly using compressed wood pellets – thanks to what we estimate will be more than £10 billion (US$13 billion) in subsidies.
Advertisement

These subsidies are provided under the premise that burning biomass is carbon neutral, that all the carbon released from burning trees is reabsorbed when new trees are grown. This logic is no longer supported by the latest scientific evidence, which shows that burning wood for power is often not carbon neutral, and can be more polluting than coal.

Our recent analysis found that Drax is the biggest emitter in Britain, pumping out 13.2 million tonnes of carbon dioxide from its chimneys in 2020. This also makes it the European Union’s fourth-largest carbon dioxide emitter among coal plants when biomass emissions are included.

03:07

Climate deal to ‘phase down’ coal reached at COP26 as nations seek to avert climate disaster

Climate deal to ‘phase down’ coal reached at COP26 as nations seek to avert climate disaster

Yet, surprisingly, most people, including many policymakers, did not realise how dirty this energy could be, and were shocked to learn just how much money meant to reduce carbon emissions was being used to pump them up.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x