The Western media narrative on the war in Ukraine is preventing a resolution
- The West is keeping the fervour of war alive with a one-sided narrative that seals any window of opportunity for peace talks
- As the conflict enters its second year, the threat of escalation remains ever-present
The West rose to global dominance on the back of advances in science, which values objective truth. Yet there is no objective scientific truth when events are being viewed through a lens of emotion, anger and fear.
Inevitably, the Ukraine war is both a factual reality and a media fest. In Homage to Catalonia, an early account of the Spanish Civil War published in 1938, the British writer George Orwell noted: “One of the most horrible features of war is that all the war-propaganda, all the screaming and lies and hatred, comes invariably from the people who are not fighting.”
“Everyone believes in the atrocities of the enemy and disbelieves in those of his own side, without ever bothering to examine the evidence,” he also wrote.
In short, the war is being obfuscated by misinformation and disinformation, so much so that only a few understand the real situation or its possible outcome.
It’s hard to know who to believe any more, since the BBC, The New York Times and RT seem to be voices for their own respective deep security states.
Admittedly, no information outlet is free of vested interests. But all media channels today, including the internet, are either voices of power (the state) or money (the rich).
We should note that the role of information and systems thinking in war is a recent Western development resulting from World War II. Allied scientists from different disciplines brought together to think about the nuclear bomb and other war efforts discovered that thinking in systems is very different from thinking in parts. The collective has properties very different from that of its parts.
Classical scientific thinking until that point was linear and mechanical, moving from cause to effect and assuming that the external environment does not change. The big shift in thinking was the understanding that the whole system changes dynamically on the basis of the interaction between parts, or what are called feedback loops.
Feedback loops mean that for every action, there are consequences that are not immediately obvious. Incidents create accidents and vice versa. Thus, media propaganda has consequences we have no way of predicting. The deep state assumes that it can fool most of the people most of the time, but this cannot be done forever.
World entering dangerous era as nations choose war over diplomacy
The pioneer systems thinker and ecologist Donnella Meadows recognised that feedback loops have lags, so that the effects of any action may not be evident until later, and the interaction between different feedback loops with different lags mean that we can never predict exactly the impact of policies or new information released through the media.
Such are the lies that feed a never-ending war. Humanity will not rest till war destroys everything that is worth fighting for. But in the meantime, let’s enjoy the metaverse with its digital fantasy of a beautiful life.
Andrew Sheng writes on global issues from an Asian perspective