Ex-Met director triggers war of words over US$450m Da Vinci with Instagram post about its conservation
Thomas Campbell’s Instagram post about ‘conservations issues’ of record-shattering Salvator Mundi painting of Christ prompts biting response from one of work’s former owners, and attack on ‘bullying’ Christie’s co-chairman
PUBLISHED : Thursday, 23 November, 2017, 6:22pm
UPDATED : Thursday, 23 November, 2017, 6:22pm
Related topics
A war of words has erupted over a comment by former Metropolitan Museum of Art director Thomas Campbell on his Instagram account regarding the state of the most expensive painting ever sold at auction.
“450 million dollars?! Hope the buyer understands conservation issues …” the art historian wrote in a post that features an image of a pre-restored Salvator Mundi by Leonardo da Vinci. The artwork was sold to an unidentified buyer at Christie’s in New York last week for over US$450 million including fees.
US$450 million paid for Da Vinci painting of Jesus at New York auction, smashing art sales records
Robert Simon, one of the painting’s previous owners, then left a comment in the same post, saying: “Dr Campbell, this is an incredibly ill-informed and mean-spirited comment about one of the most respected painting conservators in the world, one who incidentally spent many years diligently working at your former institution.
“I personally observed the conservation process on the Salvator Mundi and can attest to the absolute honesty, modesty, and respect that Dianne Modestini brought to her work on the painting – carried out at the highest ethical standards of the profession.
“Given the prevalence of so many foolish remarks in both serious and social media, I have refrained from responding, but feel compelled to do so now.”
Campbell then replied: “I have greatest respect for Modestini. Was simply remarking, as so many others have, on extensive amount of conservation. Seems to be a lot of oversensitivity out there.”
Loic Gouzer, Christie’s co-chairman of post-war and contemporary art in the Americas, who consigned the Salvator Mundi for sale, also reportedly expressed his views on Campbell’s Instagram entry.
Former director of the Met on his acrimonious departure from the venerable New York museum
According to The Art Newspaper, Campbell responded to a direct message from Gouzer, saying: “My comment was a legitimate response to an extraordinary price. Christie’s doesn’t need your abusive bullying to defend itself. And my comment certainly wasn’t an attack on a highly competent conservator. If you don’t enjoy my occasional Instagram posts then don’t follow me.”
Salvator Mundi (Saviour of the World) is believed to have been painted around 1500 for King Louis XII of France. It shows Christ holding a crystal orb in his left hand and giving blessing with his right hand.
There have been lingering doubts about its authenticity since it reappeared in the market, much restored.
Most Popular
Viewed
- 1
![The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.]( "The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.")
- 2
![A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP]( "A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP")
- 3
![Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.]( "Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.")
- 4
![Tropical cyclones were named for ease of communication, first by storm forecasters for the Atlantic Ocean, who chose Christian saints’ names; Pacific Ocean storms are given native names contributed by 14 countries and regions]( "Tropical cyclones were named for ease of communication, first by storm forecasters for the Atlantic Ocean, who chose Christian saints’ names; Pacific Ocean storms are given native names contributed by 14 countries and regions")
- 5
![Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.]( "Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.")
Shared
- 1
![The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.]( "The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.")
- 2
![A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP]( "A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP")
- 3
![Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.]( "Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.")
- 4
![Steven Chan (above centre), stage manager of the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra for the past 40 years, has enjoyed being able to watch the growth and development of the orchestra, which celebrates its 45th anniversary this year. Photo: Phil Shek/HK Phil.]( "Steven Chan (above centre), stage manager of the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra for the past 40 years, has enjoyed being able to watch the growth and development of the orchestra, which celebrates its 45th anniversary this year. Photo: Phil Shek/HK Phil.")
- 5
![Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.]( "Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.")
Commented
- 1
![The new 10 per cent tariffs will rise to 25 per cent on January 1]( "The new 10 per cent tariffs will rise to 25 per cent on January 1")
- 2
![China’s ambassador to Sweden Gui Congyou wants a meeting with local authorities to discuss the alleged mistreatment of the Chinese tourists. Photo: Handout]( "China’s ambassador to Sweden Gui Congyou wants a meeting with local authorities to discuss the alleged mistreatment of the Chinese tourists. Photo: Handout")
- 3
![If the US does go ahead with tariffs on US$200 billion of Chinese goods, they will be the biggest round since the first batch on Chinese exports in July. Photo: Reuters]( "If the US does go ahead with tariffs on US$200 billion of Chinese goods, they will be the biggest round since the first batch on Chinese exports in July. Photo: Reuters")
- 4
![The Japanese submarine Kuroshio took part in military exercises in the South China Sea. Photo: Handout]( "The Japanese submarine Kuroshio took part in military exercises in the South China Sea. Photo: Handout")
- 5
![Taiwan has been trying for readmission to the United Nations since 1993 but has recently changed tactics with the launch of a charm offensive by officials and a letter-writing campaign to the world’s media. Photo: AFP]( "Taiwan has been trying for readmission to the United Nations since 1993 but has recently changed tactics with the launch of a charm offensive by officials and a letter-writing campaign to the world’s media. Photo: AFP")
You may also like
Show goes on for Steven Chan, HK Phil’s ‘Mr Fixit’ for 40 years
In partnership with: HK Phil
Friends, foes and firepower: Donald Trump’s vision for US-Asia ties is still anyone’s guess
Brought to you by: SCMP Events & Conferences
Comments: