bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

hooksAmpRedirectArticle

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

paywallTypes

createdDate

publishedDate

sponsorType

urlAlias

moreOnThisArticles

commentCount

authorLocations

authors

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

articleSpeeches

socialHeadline

headline

images

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

sponsor

pdfFiles

seriesReverseOrder

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

readingTime

customTimezone

liveContents

The Washington Post

World Without Mind: The Existential Threat of Big Tech
by Franklin Foer
Penguin Press
4 stars

Silicon Valley’s achievements are typically viewed from the perspective of innovations that have transformed modern life.
We can go back a few decades and look to Intel’s development of the integrated circuit, for instance, or Apple’s reimagining of the personal computer. More recent are planet-spanning social media platforms, such as Facebook; search engines that resemble magic mirrors, such as Google; and bazaars without end, such as Amazon.
Book review: Six Billion Shoppers, former Alibaba vice-president’s broad view of e-commerce
Many of us over 35 see this as a mixed blessing, of course: access to wondrous technological tools has also brought us too much email, too many distractions and too much vulnerability – hackings, trollings, stalkings and worse.
But what if the trade-offs are much larger than we realised? Franklin Foer argues that in the midst of our digital lives, does it not seem possible that Silicon Valley’s darkest, stealthiest triumph has been to merge personal technologies that improve our efficiency with personal technologies that alter our humanity?

On a basic level, Foer’s book aims to expose the dangers that four technology giants – Google, Apple, Facebook and Amazon – pose to our culture and careers. In their methods of consumer observation and data gathering, and in their intention to replace human decision-making with merciless algorithms, these companies, Foer says, “are shredding the principles that protect individuality”.
Actually, it is even worse than that. Bent on dominating our markets as well as the world, the four corporations have lulled us into a sense of pliant dependency as they influence our thinking and activities. Far more powerful than the elite “gatekeeping” institutions of the past – the major television networks, for example, or the leading newspapers – this fearsome four, as Foer characterises them, are the new arbiters of media, economy, politics and the arts.
By making their services cheap and indispensable, and by tailoring their complex algorithms to our data profiles, they can gently push us toward products they want us to buy or, say, YouTube videos they want us to watch. Yet the methods by which we get such recommendations – for news, consumer goods, movies, music, friends and the like – remain opaque.
When we outsource thinking to machines, we are really outsourcing thinking to the organisations that run the machines
Franklin Foer
Facebook’s acceptance of thousands of Russian ads during last year’s US presidential election may be a case in point. As Foer reminds us, through an algorithmic dispersal of misinformation, the social media giant possibly helped elect to the presidency of the United States a frequently bankrupt real estate developer without any political experience whatsoever.
The heart of the problem, as Foer sees it, “is that when we outsource thinking to machines, we are really outsourcing thinking to the organisations that run the machines”. It is an important distinction.
Foer isn’t an anti-technology zealot; he admits to being a Twitter addict and an enthusiastic user of screens and smartphones, even as he admits that his favourite indulgence is reading a book in his bathtub at home.
What he most wants us to see, though, is how the companies that dominate the world’s technology ecosystem have assumed the roles of monopolists (even if, by an economist’s definition, they more closely resemble oligopolies – they are immensely powerful within certain markets, such as web search or social media, where there is limited competition).

Monopolies or quasi-monopolies that seem to be exploiting consumers have of course long been targets for government scrutiny. But Foer thinks advanced technologies may be creating a more dangerous situation than what we have experienced in the past. The tech companies’ wealth, market share, ingenuity and growing power within the US government make them increasingly formidable.
As Foer frequently points out: “We have begun to outsource our intellectual work to companies that suggest what we should learn, the topics we should consider.” But by carving out for themselves immense networks of influence and intelligence, these companies, he argues, have also developed what may prove to be unassailable advantages. They know our preferences better than their upstart competitors ever could, so the more they win, the more they win. And the longer this goes on, Foer fears, the worse it will get.
His essential point seems to be this: that at the very least we should pause and consider acting, on both a public and a personal level, before we find that we have lost more of what makes us human – our individuality, instrumentality and spontaneity – than we ever bargained for. So, too, should we do something before we discover that the creative industries that support our culture have been so eroded by lower wages and machine learning that they are in danger of infrastructural collapse.

We might ask if this is an unwinnable battle. We love technology; we need technology. And in an era when regulation has increasingly fallen out of favour, the likelihood in the near future of a tight harnessing of big tech (or a wholesale revamping of governments’ antitrust policies) seems unlikely.
But it is reasonable to believe, judging by the growth trajectory and ravenous appetites of the tech giants, that their day of reckoning will eventually come – just as it came for monopolies such as US telecoms giant AT&T. Until then, Foer suggests that a number of refusenik-like decisions – reading a book on paper, say, rather than in an electronic format which allows for information on our reading habits to be collected – are a good place to draw the line.
Book review: To Siri With Love, an autistic child’s mother gives thanks to tireless digital friend
Even if innovations in personal technology cannot be stopped, their true value should always be questioned. And it is not hypocritical to embrace some technologies while rejecting others. As Foer reminds us, the stakes are high, the marketing pitch is deafening, and saying no to big tech – at least sometimes – is an increasingly crucial matter of personal choice and civic responsibility.


How China could dominate AI era’s ‘tokenomics’ with vast power grids and low-cost models

Alibaba chairman Joe Tsai credits China’s AI edge to power grid, open-source models

OpenClaw, government support fuel rise of 1-person companies in China

In Kunshan, China’s Foxconn nerve centre, old tech tries to learn new tricks

Artificial intelligence

Book review: World Without Mind – how big four tech firms are taking over our lives and why we need to do something about it

Amazon, headed by CEO Jeff Bezos, is one of the four big tech firms that author Franklin Foer warns are ‘shredding the principles that protect individuality’. Photo: AP

World Without Mind cover

FILE - This Thursday, Jan. 3, 2013, file photo shows Google's headquarters in Mountain View, Calif. Google's new head of diversity has rejected an internal commentary from an employee who suggested women don't get ahead in tech jobs because of biological differences. The dueling memos come as Silicon Valley grapples with accusations of sexism and discrimination and companies like Google, Facebook and Uber say they are trying to change. Google is also in the midst of a Department of Labor investigation into whether it pays women less than men. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez, File)

FILE PHOTO: A 3D plastic representation of the Facebook logo is seen in this photo illustration May 13, 2015. To match Analysis INTERNET-POLITICS/ REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration/File Photo

FILE PHOTO: Apple CEO Tim Cook waves as he arrives on stage to deliver his keynote address at the Worldwide Developers Conference in San Francisco, California, U.S. June 8, 2015. REUTERS/Robert Galbraith/File Photo

To Siri With Love, an autistic child’s mother gives thanks to tireless digital friend

Judith Newman gives heart-warming insight into autism through her son’s relationship with Apple’s virtual assistant

To Siri With Love by Judith Newman

Six Billion Shoppers, former Alibaba vice-president’s broad view of e-commerce

The owner of a Taobao online store prepares packages in Ningbo, Zhejiang province. Picture: Alamy

Six Billion Shoppers by Porter Erisman

Handout Image shows Porter Erisman, author of Six Billion Shoppers. [15OCTOBER2017 POST MAGAZINE]

A customer uses an Indian Rupee banknote to pay for a purchase as a sign for PayTM online payment method, operated by One97 Communications Ltd., is displayed at a stall selling snacks in Bengaluru, India, on Saturday, Feb. 4, 2017. A relative laggard in digital transactions, India has more recently seen 50 percent year-on-year growth, according to a study by Google and Boston Consulting Group. The pace may accelerate with demonetization giving digital wallets like Paytm, MobiKwik and Freecharge an extra push. Photographer: Dhiraj Singh/Bloomberg

Chatbots set to take over most customer service work, say Hong Kong start-ups

A general view shows the skyline of the Central district of Hong Kong on June 27, 2017. Hong Kong will mark the 20th anniversary of the handover from British to Chinese rule on July 1, 2017. / AFP PHOTO / Anthony WALLACE

This image shows a detail of iPhone 7 smartphone screen showing Siri voice control button. Photo: May Tse

Several Hong Kong start-ups are working on chatbot applications that converse in Cantonese. Photo: Shutterstock

Culture

Books

Author Franklin Foer says that with Google, Apple, Amazon and Facebook eroding what makes us human and lulling us into an ever greater sense of pliant dependency, the time has come to start saying no to big tech


An assessment or critique of a service, product or creative endeavour.  Film reviews, restaurant reviews, reviews of art exhibitions. (Eg. Crazy Rich Asians: an important film, yes, but a good one?)


Review