Film review: The Shack – Octavia Spencer plays God in bland faith-based drama
An adaptation of a self-published novel that become a US bestseller, The Shack veers between the risible and the ludicrous, with bizarre scenes and unfunny in-jokes
PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 18 April, 2017, 7:01am
UPDATED : Tuesday, 18 April, 2017, 7:01am
Related topics
1.5/5 stars
The Christian God is rarely shown figuratively in movies, and The Shack is a good example of why not. In Stuart Hazeldine’s film, the deity is played by Octavia Spencer as a cheerful, no-nonsense matriarch who’s temporarily hanging out in a house in the woods. As if that’s not mind-boggling enough, Jesus (Avraham Aviv Alush) is depicted as a groovy guy with top-notch carpentry skills, and the Holy Spirit (Sumire Matsubara) as a Disney-esque heroine with all the answers.
The Shack is based on a self-published novel by Canadian author William P. Young. It was an unexpected bestseller, although religious commentators variously judged the tome heretical or just plain silly.
Film review: Silence – Martin Scorsese’s sombre meditation on faith and resilience
The story focuses on a family man (Sam Worthington) whose young daughter is abducted and murdered by a serial killer. A mysterious note invites him to visit the site of the crime – the shack of the title – where he finds himself face-to-face with the Holy Trinity. The Trinity teach him about forgiveness.
The result lands somewhere between risible and ludicrous, and the film’s suffocating blandness would make this a better fit for cable TV, where the intended audience of undemanding Christian viewers could seek it out. On the big screen, its faults are magnified. A scene where the hero walks on water with Jesus is bizarre, and the in-jokes about the Trinity all being the same entity are just not funny.
Film review: The Young Messiah – action-star Jesus aimed at Christians and their children
The moral thrust of the movie is light on scripture, and never gets deeper than we should forgive evil people because bad things in their past might have made them commit their crimes.
The Shack opens on April 20
Want more articles like this? Follow SCMP Film on Facebook
Most Popular
Viewed
- 1
![The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.]( "The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.")
- 2
![A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP]( "A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP")
- 3
![Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.]( "Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.")
- 4
![Tropical cyclones were named for ease of communication, first by storm forecasters for the Atlantic Ocean, who chose Christian saints’ names; Pacific Ocean storms are given native names contributed by 14 countries and regions]( "Tropical cyclones were named for ease of communication, first by storm forecasters for the Atlantic Ocean, who chose Christian saints’ names; Pacific Ocean storms are given native names contributed by 14 countries and regions")
- 5
![Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.]( "Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.")
Shared
- 1
![The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.]( "The piano duo of Jennifer Rüth (left) and Ming, known as the Queenz of Piano, who will perform their dynamic acrobatic musical show, mixing classical, pop and rock music in Hong Kong on November 17.")
- 2
![A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP]( "A Chinese tourist frolics with a cabaret performer at ZAG, a gay bar in Thailand’s southern tourist destination of Phuket. Photo: AFP")
- 3
![Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.]( "Japanese game developer Yoshihisa Kurosawa says he is baffled by the cult success of his low-budget Hong Kong 97 video game.")
- 4
![Steven Chan (above centre), stage manager of the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra for the past 40 years, has enjoyed being able to watch the growth and development of the orchestra, which celebrates its 45th anniversary this year. Photo: Phil Shek/HK Phil.]( "Steven Chan (above centre), stage manager of the Hong Kong Philharmonic Orchestra for the past 40 years, has enjoyed being able to watch the growth and development of the orchestra, which celebrates its 45th anniversary this year. Photo: Phil Shek/HK Phil.")
- 5
![Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.]( "Jessica Henwick as Colleen Wing in Marvel's Iron Fist on Netflix.")
Commented
- 1
![US President Donald Trump speaks in the White House on Monday. Photo: pool via EPA-EFE]( "US President Donald Trump speaks in the White House on Monday. Photo: pool via EPA-EFE")
- 2
![If the US does go ahead with tariffs on US$200 billion of Chinese goods, they will be the biggest round since the first batch on Chinese exports in July. Photo: Reuters]( "If the US does go ahead with tariffs on US$200 billion of Chinese goods, they will be the biggest round since the first batch on Chinese exports in July. Photo: Reuters")
- 3
![China’s ambassador to Sweden Gui Congyou wants a meeting with local authorities to discuss the alleged mistreatment of the Chinese tourists. Photo: Handout]( "China’s ambassador to Sweden Gui Congyou wants a meeting with local authorities to discuss the alleged mistreatment of the Chinese tourists. Photo: Handout")
- 4
![The Japanese submarine Kuroshio took part in military exercises in the South China Sea. Photo: Handout]( "The Japanese submarine Kuroshio took part in military exercises in the South China Sea. Photo: Handout")
- 5
![Taiwan has been trying for readmission to the United Nations since 1993 but has recently changed tactics with the launch of a charm offensive by officials and a letter-writing campaign to the world’s media. Photo: AFP]( "Taiwan has been trying for readmission to the United Nations since 1993 but has recently changed tactics with the launch of a charm offensive by officials and a letter-writing campaign to the world’s media. Photo: AFP")
You may also like
Wearable monitors can help your heart if you know your device
In partnership with: Hong Kong Adventist Hospital
Space to Grow
Brought to you by: Shrewsbury International School
Comments: