How did Hong Kong mobster movie Chasing the Dragon get past China’s censors? By bashing the British
By granting director Wong Jing a lucrative release during the National Day holidays, Chinese authorities have signalled that Hong Kong gangsters can be seen in a patriotic light – if their stories are set before the 1997 handover
PUBLISHED : Friday, 29 September, 2017, 6:01pm
UPDATED : Friday, 29 September, 2017, 6:01pm
Related topics
Mobsters, murder, mayhem – Chasing the Dragon is a misfit among the morally unambiguous home-grown blockbusters opening in Chinese cinemas tomorrow ahead of the National Day holidays.
Considering the uncontrolled violence and unpunished crimes Chasing the Dragon depicts, it’s surprising Hong Kong director Wong Jing’s film has received such approval in the face of an official clampdown on what may be screened ahead of the Chinese Communist Party’s 19th national congress next month.
Feng Xiaogang’s Youth (Fanghua), whose story spans the Cultural Revolution, the 1979 Sino-Vietnamese war and the so-called Anti-Spiritual Pollution Campaign in 1983, was reportedly denied a release during the lucrative “golden week” holidays because it flirts with historical issues that could be considered controversial.
Hong Kong filmmaker Johnnie To Kei-fung’s widely acclaimed mob thrillers have never been released in China – apart from the 2005 film Election, which got a screening licence only after its distributors changed the ending so that the last ruffian standing is revealed to be an undercover cop.
The Chinese authorities have always viewed Hong Kong gangster films, with their slick underworld chieftain characters, as unfit and improper entertainment – so what’s different about Chasing the Dragon? Its wrongdoers do not necessarily get their dues.
Based on a real-life police sergeant who reportedly amassed a fortune of HK$500 million through kickbacks in the 1960s, Andy Lau Tak-wah’s character, Lee Rock, ends the film living in comfortable exile in Canada.
Donnie Yen Ji-dan’s Crippled Ho – a take on the illegal-drugs kingpin Ng Sik-ho – did time for his misdeeds, but is shown reunited with his family after his release from prison on parole in 1990.
Why, then, would China’s censors give Chasing the Dragon the all-clear? The key is the period in which the film is set – and the way its creator riffed on its importance to celebrating Hong Kong’s return to Chinese rule.
In texts which spool across the screen at the film’s beginning and end, the 62-year-old screenwriter-director goes out of his way to point out how Lee Rock and Crippled Ho flourished in a system sanctioned and shielded by the colonial authorities – a stance the director reiterated in an interview with the Post in which he proclaims that the British “didn’t do anything good for Hongkongers”.
British colonialism’s legacy in Hong Kong is more complex than self-proclaimed patriot Wong makes out, but his simplistic representation of Hong Kong’s history aligns with Beijing’s stance, as state-sanctioned media try to contain nostalgia in some circles for life as it was before the city’s return to Chinese rule 20 years ago.
Chasing the Dragon could mark a watershed in Chinese-language filmmaking, allowing directors a way to unleash long-suppressed stories about crime and corruption in a dark, fatalist world – as long as all the bad things happen under the aegis of brutal, evil foreigners in pre-1997 Hong Kong.
Previously, early 20th century China has frequently been the backdrop for warlords, politicians, entrepreneurs and femmes fatales as they battle for supremacy with dirty deals and blood-soaked schemes.
Starting with Zhang Yimou’s The Shanghai Triads (1995) and Chen Kaige’s Temptress Moon (1996), directors have played up the lawlessness of 1930s China for very different ends: Jiang Wen’s Let the Bullets Fly and Derek Yee Tung-shing’s The Great Magician are allegories about present-day China, while Feng Xiaogang’s A World Without Thieves and Wong Jing’s The Last Tycoon are more simplistic entertainment.
Whatever their directors’ intentions, these films were passed by censors because they did not explicitly mention or address the social and political turmoil in China after 1949. Instead, they produced what can be seen as a chaotic prologue to the establishment of the People’s Republic and its ending of the anarchy, superstition and social injustices of Kuomintang rule.
This take on history is evident in so-called main melody films – those showing past military engagements or profiling first generation Communist Party leaders – such as Beginning of the Great Revival and The Founding of an Army , in which Nationalist leader Chiang Kai-shek and his associates are largely depicted as arch-villains of a decadent era.
Does Wong Jing’s Chasing the Dragon, with its patriotic repackaging of Hong Kong underworld history, lend a new dimension to promoting love of country that other filmmakers can echo? Before China resumed sovereignty over the city, then-public security minister Tao Siju praised some Hong Kong gangsters as patriotic, a remark some saw as a request for their help in stabilising the city ahead of its handover from British rule.
If real-life gangsters could be brought onside in such a way, no doubt films portraying them could play their part in promoting the virtues of unity.
Chasing the Dragon is in cinemas now
Want more articles like this? Follow SCMP Film on Facebook
Most Popular
Viewed
- 1
![Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’]( "Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’")
- 2
![Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA]( "Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA")
- 3
![Henry Golding and Constance Wu arrive at the red carpet. Wu wears a look from Ralph & Russo. Photo: AFP]( "Henry Golding and Constance Wu arrive at the red carpet. Wu wears a look from Ralph & Russo. Photo: AFP")
- 4
![On Sunday, the Hong Kong pop star died from a suspected suicide. Reporter Vivienne Chow looks back on her last meeting with the singer, where she appeared to have come to terms with her sexuality and bipolar disorder]( "On Sunday, the Hong Kong pop star died from a suspected suicide. Reporter Vivienne Chow looks back on her last meeting with the singer, where she appeared to have come to terms with her sexuality and bipolar disorder")
- 5
![President Donald Trump takes a beating in Rick Wilson’s book Everything Trump Touches Dies. Photo: AP]( "President Donald Trump takes a beating in Rick Wilson’s book Everything Trump Touches Dies. Photo: AP")
Shared
- 1
![Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’]( "Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’")
- 2
![Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA]( "Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA")
- 3
![On Sunday, the Hong Kong pop star died from a suspected suicide. Reporter Vivienne Chow looks back on her last meeting with the singer, where she appeared to have come to terms with her sexuality and bipolar disorder]( "On Sunday, the Hong Kong pop star died from a suspected suicide. Reporter Vivienne Chow looks back on her last meeting with the singer, where she appeared to have come to terms with her sexuality and bipolar disorder")
- 4
![Henry Golding and Constance Wu arrive at the red carpet. Wu wears a look from Ralph & Russo. Photo: AFP]( "Henry Golding and Constance Wu arrive at the red carpet. Wu wears a look from Ralph & Russo. Photo: AFP")
- 5
![The mixed-race actor who plays the leading man in the big-screen adaptation of Kevin Kwan’s novel talks about his struggle with identity issues of the sort the film raises, and how losing his anonymity is a price he’s willing to pay for stardom]( "The mixed-race actor who plays the leading man in the big-screen adaptation of Kevin Kwan’s novel talks about his struggle with identity issues of the sort the film raises, and how losing his anonymity is a price he’s willing to pay for stardom")
Commented
- 1
![Chinese foreign ministry and Hong Kong government condemn him and FCC for providing a platform to voice ‘unacceptable’ view that independence is only solution for city]( "Chinese foreign ministry and Hong Kong government condemn him and FCC for providing a platform to voice ‘unacceptable’ view that independence is only solution for city")
- 2
![An analyst has warned that increased censorship by Beijing would affect Hong Kong’s future liveability rankings as companies leave. Photo: EPA]( "An analyst has warned that increased censorship by Beijing would affect Hong Kong’s future liveability rankings as companies leave. Photo: EPA")
- 3
![China’s Southern Theatre Command, whose area of responsibility includes the South China Sea, said its frigates had recently been involved in a naval exercise, but did not give an exact location. Photo: Weixin.qq.com]( "China’s Southern Theatre Command, whose area of responsibility includes the South China Sea, said its frigates had recently been involved in a naval exercise, but did not give an exact location. Photo: Weixin.qq.com")
- 4
![US President Donald Trump signs the John McCain National Defence Authorisation Act at a ceremony on Monday in Fort Drum, New York. Photo: AP]( "US President Donald Trump signs the John McCain National Defence Authorisation Act at a ceremony on Monday in Fort Drum, New York. Photo: AP")
- 5
![Foreign ministry calls for ‘objective perspective’ from Washington after it says strategic competition with China is a ‘principal priority’]( "Foreign ministry calls for ‘objective perspective’ from Washington after it says strategic competition with China is a ‘principal priority’")
You may also like
Highs and lows of out-of-this-world, deep-sea music performances
In partnership with: Leisure and Cultural Services Department
Comments: