The Monkey King 3 film review: Soi Cheang’s fantasy adaptation turns to love in its various forms
Third instalment of this latest adaptation of the Chinese Ming dynasty novel Journey to the West sees the Monkey King, monk Xuanzang and their demon friends trapped in Womanland, where falling in love is the only way out
PUBLISHED : Wednesday, 14 February, 2018, 12:04pm
UPDATED : Wednesday, 14 February, 2018, 12:04pm
Related topics
2.5/5 stars
The first of Soi Cheang Pou-soi’s CGI-laden adaptations of Ming dynasty novel Journey to the West, in 2014, was disappointing; 2016 sequel The Monkey King 2 was much improved – a thrilling action fantasy that didn’t shy away from darker moral issues – and it’s the quartet of lead actors from that film who have reunited to continue their pilgrimage for a third instalment.
In The Monkey King 3, Buddhist monk Xuanzang (William Feng Shaofeng) and his disciples – Wukong the Monkey King (Aaron Kwok Fu-shing), pig demon Bajie (Xiao Shenyang) and the blue-skinned sand demon Wujing (Him Lo Chung-him) – inadvertently enter the Womanland of Western Liang, a nation populated by women raised to believe that men are fatally deceptive in matters of the heart.
Love nevertheless blossoms between Xuanzang and the Womanland’s young queen (Zhao Liying), even though her royal preceptor (Gigi Leung Wing-kei) is hell-bent on sentencing the men to death. As Wukong and Co. search for a way out of this nation surrounded by a vast magical net, it soon transpires, conveniently, that romantic love is the only key to opening the gate.
Film review – Journey to the West: The Demons Strike Back finds Stephen Chow and Tsui Hark on autopilot
So will Xuanzang give up on his sacred mission and stay with the queen? The question, as rhetorical as it sounds, is central to this visually striking comic drama, which curiously sidelines the disciples and offers barely a memorable fight sequence – a big departure from The Monkey King 2, whose action was choreographed by Sammo Hung Kam-bo.
While the film has intriguing elements, including a poorly handled chapter on abortion and an androgynous river god (Lin Chi-ling) who was jilted by a human lover, the profound love Cheang sets out to depict remains tantalisingly out of reach right up to the film’s philosophical conclusion.
Film review: Wu Kong – Eddie Peng plays the Monkey King in Derek Kwok’s anti-establishment parable
Having eschewed the usual depictions of Wukong causing supernatural mayhem, The Monkey King 3 stands or falls on its musings about love in all its forms – and they’re largely unsatisfying.
The Monkey King 3 opens on February 15
Want more articles like this? Follow SCMP Film on Facebook
Most Popular
Viewed
- 1
![Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA]( "Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA")
- 2
![Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’]( "Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’")
- 3
![Chinese American actress who plays female lead Rachel Chu in Kevin Kwan novel adaptation talks about growing up in Virginia, following her dreams with her family’s support, and how she pushed to secure her role]( "Chinese American actress who plays female lead Rachel Chu in Kevin Kwan novel adaptation talks about growing up in Virginia, following her dreams with her family’s support, and how she pushed to secure her role")
- 4
![Walt Disney Studios tweeted the first image of Liu Yifei as the famed Chinese heroine for the live-action Mulan on Monday]( "Walt Disney Studios tweeted the first image of Liu Yifei as the famed Chinese heroine for the live-action Mulan on Monday")
- 5
![The mixed-race actor who plays the leading man in the big-screen adaptation of Kevin Kwan’s novel talks about his struggle with identity issues of the sort the film raises, and how losing his anonymity is a price he’s willing to pay for stardom]( "The mixed-race actor who plays the leading man in the big-screen adaptation of Kevin Kwan’s novel talks about his struggle with identity issues of the sort the film raises, and how losing his anonymity is a price he’s willing to pay for stardom")
Shared
- 1
![Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’]( "Malaysian actress can’t wait to see how her friends in Asia react to the film of Kevin Kwan’s novel about Asian high society, and says she worked hard to make her character relatable in a film that’s ‘very representative of who we are’")
- 2
![Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA]( "Chinese actress Li Bingbing attends the US premiere of “The Meg”at the TCL Chinese Theatre IMAX in Hollywood. Photo: EPA")
- 3
![Chinese American actress who plays female lead Rachel Chu in Kevin Kwan novel adaptation talks about growing up in Virginia, following her dreams with her family’s support, and how she pushed to secure her role]( "Chinese American actress who plays female lead Rachel Chu in Kevin Kwan novel adaptation talks about growing up in Virginia, following her dreams with her family’s support, and how she pushed to secure her role")
- 4
![Walt Disney Studios tweeted the first image of Liu Yifei as the famed Chinese heroine for the live-action Mulan on Monday]( "Walt Disney Studios tweeted the first image of Liu Yifei as the famed Chinese heroine for the live-action Mulan on Monday")
- 5
![The mixed-race actor who plays the leading man in the big-screen adaptation of Kevin Kwan’s novel talks about his struggle with identity issues of the sort the film raises, and how losing his anonymity is a price he’s willing to pay for stardom]( "The mixed-race actor who plays the leading man in the big-screen adaptation of Kevin Kwan’s novel talks about his struggle with identity issues of the sort the film raises, and how losing his anonymity is a price he’s willing to pay for stardom")
Commented
- 1
![Claims of instability are overblown but discontent is widespread – and it has been amplified by officials who stick fingers in their ears and dial up the propaganda]( "Claims of instability are overblown but discontent is widespread – and it has been amplified by officials who stick fingers in their ears and dial up the propaganda")
- 2
![People walk past a poster featuring Chinese President Xi Jinping with a slogan reading "Chinese Dream, People's Dream" in Beijing. Xi’s medium-to-long-term plans, in particular its plan to move up the value chain and compete directly with the US in manufacturing through the Made in China 2025 campaign, are the true targets of the US trade war, rather than trade imbalances. Photo: AFP]( "People walk past a poster featuring Chinese President Xi Jinping with a slogan reading \"Chinese Dream, People's Dream\" in Beijing. Xi’s medium-to-long-term plans, in particular its plan to move up the value chain and compete directly with the US in manufacturing through the Made in China 2025 campaign, are the true targets of the US trade war, rather than trade imbalances. Photo: AFP")
- 3
![Riyadh’s over-the-top reaction to Ottawa’s request that it free a women’s rights activist is a familiar one to countries that have challenged Beijing’s human rights record]( "Riyadh’s over-the-top reaction to Ottawa’s request that it free a women’s rights activist is a familiar one to countries that have challenged Beijing’s human rights record")
- 4
![Illustration: Craig Stephens]( "Illustration: Craig Stephens")
- 5
![Boris Johnson is a cross between a head injury and an unmade bed, according to comedian Trevor Noah. Photo: Twitter]( "Boris Johnson is a cross between a head injury and an unmade bed, according to comedian Trevor Noah. Photo: Twitter")
You may also like
Will super-fast 5G internet really change the world?
In partnership with: HKT PREMIER
Comments: