‘The same men at the top’: film sexism row erupts at Venice festival, as director decries lack of films directed by women
With only one of 21 films in competition at festival that kicks off Oscars race directed by women, female representation has become a hot-button issue, with a French male filmmaker calling for action to redress the imbalance
French director Jacques Audiard went gunning for sexism in the film industry on Sunday after his extraordinary new Western, The Sisters Brothers, received a standing ovation at the Venice film festival.
The maker of A Prophet – whose first American movie stars Joaquin Phoenix, John C. Reilly and Jake Gyllenhaal – is the early favourite to pick up the Golden Lion for best film.
But as he basked in the applause of critics, Audiard blasted the festival’s organisers with both barrels for choosing only one film by a woman to vie for the top prize.
“I was surprised when I read that the line-up was 20 men against one woman,” Audiard said. “I wrote to the other directors but there wasn’t much a reaction,” he added.
The filmmaker attacked the “opaque” way films were picked for big prizes, adding that “in the 25 years my films have been competing, I have never seen a woman at the head of a festival”.
His comments come after Venice – now the key launch pad for the Oscars race – was accused of “toxic masculinity” for all but cold-shouldering women directors for a second year in succession.
Festival director Alberto Barbera even threatened to quit rather than give in to quotas before Venice bowed Friday to the 50/50 by 2020 equality goals already signed by Cannes and other festivals.
He had insisted that films should be chosen on merit and not on the filmmaker’s gender.
But Audiard – who faces stiff competition in a rich and starry Venice line-up – was having none of it. “Let’s stop thinking about the sex of film, it doesn’t make sense.
“We can, however, count equality – it’s very simple … When we start getting serious we can avoid aberrations like 20 against one.”
When his words were met with loud applause, Audiard declared, “No, don’t clap – we have to act!”
Audiard said that he was not attacking Barbera’s integrity, but that “there was a problem [in the industry]. The other problem is that for 25 years we have had the same people at the top, the same men, who have changed a little bit, but who are still there.”
Earlier, Oscar-nominated actress Berenice Bejo, who starred in The Artist, said women had to be strong and learn to say no.
“The world is controlled by men and the [film] industry too,” she said after her powerful new female Argentine drama, The Quietude, by El Clan director Pablo Trapero, was also cheered by critics.
“The world is changing [with #MeToo] but we have not yet won,” said the Paris-based star, also known for her role in the art house hit The Past.
“When I feel humiliated [on a film] or not in the right place I say no. I play women the way I think they should be played. I’m not scared to say what I think.
“When you have strong mother and father who tell you can be what you want, you will be strong enough to say no,” she added.
The Sister Brothers star Reilly – who co-produced the film after getting the rights to Patrick deWitt’s darkly comic bestseller set in the lawless Far West of the 1850s – wore a pin supporting the 50/50 to the premiere.
He compared the period to the “crisis point … we are in now”.
“The way we arrived to that place was through brutality and violence and genocide, and the strongest prevailing over the weak. But that is not a sustainable plan for the future, that is self-destructive,” Reilly said.
Despite the dearth of female directors, Venice has hummed with films with female-led stories and strong female characters.
As well as The Quietude and the adaptation of the first of Elena Ferrante’s Neapolitan novels, My Brilliant Friend, singer Lady Gaga has shone in A Star is Born, while British star Maxime Peake is the heart around which Mike Leigh’s historical epic Peterloo hangs.
Alfonso Cuaron’s highly praised Roma is centred on two resourceful Mexican maids, and even the blood-soaked arty horror flick Suspiria, by last year’s Oscar winner Luca Guadagnino, is set in a kind of feminist Berlin coven.
The Golden Lion for best film will be awarded next Saturday at the glittering ceremony on the Venice Lido.