-
Advertisement
Harvey Weinstein
CultureMusic

What Harvey Weinstein scandal means for misbehaving musicians used to getting away with it

Singers have for years survived accusations of misconduct and found forgiveness through their songs. The movie mogul’s disgrace may mean they’ll face more serious consequences in the future

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
Harvey Weinstein’s long history of alleged sexual misconduct has caused a huge backlash in Hollywood. Photo: Reuters
Tribune News Service
Last month, before stories of Harvey Weinstein’s long history of alleged sexual misconduct triggered an unprecedented outpouring in Hollywood, the disgraced movie mogul responded to accusations against him by invoking the words of Jay-Z.

“‘I’m not the man I thought I was and I better be that man for my children’,” Weinstein quoted the rapper as saying in his song 4:44, in which Jay-Z alludes to cheating. Weinstein added: “The same is true for me.”

Super-producer Harvey Weinstein apologises after sexual harassment claims

With its flippant tone and its defensive reference to the 1960s and ’70s – “when all the rules about behaviour and workplaces were different” – Weinstein’s written statement displayed a stunning misapprehension of alleged behaviour that now has been described by more than 50 women. (The statement also got Jay-Z’s lyrics completely wrong, clumsily paraphrasing a few lines from 4:44.)

Advertisement

But it’s not hard to understand why Weinstein looked to a musician in his bid for absolution. For decades, singers, rappers and guitar players have weathered accusations of misconduct – from infidelity to far, far worse – with little or sometimes no discernible damage to their careers.

The explanations are as numerous as they are dissatisfying, from the prevalence of shadowy workplaces like recording studios and tour buses to the lack of even the meagre protections some film and TV performers say they receive from the actors’ guild.

Advertisement
Weinstein tired to defend his actions by paraphrasing a few lines from the Jay-Z (pictured) song 4:44. Photo: AP
Weinstein tired to defend his actions by paraphrasing a few lines from the Jay-Z (pictured) song 4:44. Photo: AP
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x