Advertisement
Advertisement
Currency war
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Traders work at the New York Stock Exchange on August 5, 2019 at Wall Street in New York City. Selling on Wall Street accelerated early on Monday as a steep drop in the Chinese yuan escalated the US-China trade war following President Trump's announcement of new tariffs last week. Photo: AFP

China and US mutual mistrust brought economic superpowers to brink of currency war, analysts say

  • China allowed the yuan to weaken beyond a key level on Monday to follow market trends, but the timing was off, according to market watchers
  • Washington labelling China as a currency manipulator ratcheted up trade war but neglected Beijing’s rationale for allow the yuan to fall, others observed
Currency war

This week’s escalation of the US-China trade war into a broader conflict over currencies shows the dangers of diminishing trust and goodwill on both sides, leading to unintended policy consequences, analysts said.

On Monday, the People’s Bank of China (PBOC) allowed the yuan to weaken beyond the key psychological threshold of 7 to the US dollar, which led to the United States to officially labelling the world’s second biggest economy a “currency manipulator” for the first time since 1994.
However, analysts say that China’s central bank had found the yuan increasingly burdensome to defend and, therefore, its decision to allow it to drop below 7 was reasonable and long overdue, amid lower growth and escalating trade tensions with the US.

Trang Thuy Le, a forex strategist with Macquarie Group in Hong Kong, who correctly predicted in July that yuan would weaken below 7 in the third quarter, said the move was not an indication that Beijing intended to start a currency feud. “It is a delayed adjustment to economic fundamentals rather than the start of a currency war,” Trang said.

But to US President Donald Trump, the yuan’s decline was a clear signal that Beijing was manipulating its currency. “China dropped the price of their currency to an almost a historic low. It’s called ‘currency manipulation’,” he tweeted.

The US Treasury Department swiftly moved to officially label China a currency manipulator, potentially laying the groundwork for higher tariffs and other sanctions against China. Fears over this significant escalation in tensions roiled global financial markets.

Shen Jianguang, the chief economist for JD Digit and a veteran Chinese economy watcher, said Beijing’s timing in allowing the yuan to weaken below 7 was ill-chosen, given that Washington was no longer willing to give Beijing the benefit of the doubt. In this atmosphere of mistrust, the episode offered Trump an excuse to ratchet up the trade war.

“It’s good that China wants the market to play a bigger role [in setting the yuan exchange rate], but [the yuan’s move] was inevitably read by the US side as a deliberately hostile move to offset tariff effects,” Shen said. “As it turned out, the US response was stronger than China probably expected.”

A PBOC statement on Monday morning argued that the yuan’s drop was related to “expectations of additional tariffs on Chinese products”, the only line in a 1,600-character statement that backed Trump’s theory that Beijing was deliberately weakening the yuan in response the threat of a new 10 per cent tariff on $300 billion of Chinese goods.

In a statement, China’s central bank said part of its reason for allowing the yuan to float below 7 to the US dollar was the “expectations of additional tariffs on Chinese products”. Photo: Reuters.

But that was enough, in itself, to fuel currency war concerns. Part of this statement was used by the US Treasury to justify its decision to designate China as a currency manipulator.

But on Monday evening – reportedly after Washington directly conveyed its displeasure to Beijing – PBOC governor Yi Gang pledged in a statement that Beijing would not use the yuan as a weapon in trade disputes. China would stick to its G20 commitment to refrain from a competitive devaluation of its currency, he said, arguing that Beijing’s efforts to maintain a stable exchange rate in recent years “can be witnessed by all”.

Yi’s statement failed to win over US Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, who moved ahead with the designation, bringing the bilateral relationship between the world’s two largest economies to a new low and causing a sharp slide in global financial markets.

Yu Yongding, an adviser to Beijing on exchange rate policy, was appalled at the US decision.

“It is ridiculous to label [China] a currency manipulator simply because of one small exchange rate change on one trading day,” Yu, a fellow at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, told the South China Morning Post in an interview. “The US is trying to start a currency war and it has rushed to find an excuse [to do so].”

In the two days since, China’s central bank has moved to support the yuan’s value, including setting stronger-than-expected midpoint prices for the yuan’s daily trading range and announcing a plan to sell yuan securities in Hong Kong to soak up yuan liquidity and so support its exchange rate.

In addition, China’s major state banks were active in supporting the yuan in the onshore market, Reuters reported.

Hua Changchun, an economist with Guotai Junan Securities, a brokerage, said Beijing and Washington have been groping around in the “fog of war”, with each side trying to guess the other’s true intentions and possible next steps.

Some analysts said that this week’s dramatic currency spat shows that neither side is interested or expectant of a trade deal. Photo: AFP

“China apparently did not expect the US to react in such a fierce manner,” Hua said. “Now the situation has become very difficult to handle.”

According to Arthur Kroeber, head of research at economic consulting firm Gavekal Dragonomics, the currency spat reflects a significant thinning in the goodwill between Beijing and Washington.

Beijing’s decision to allow the yuan to weaken “signals that Beijing thinks a trade deal is no longer a plausible prospect”. In turn, the US response to place the currency manipulator tag on China “signals that the Trump administration is no longer very interested in seeking a deal”, Kroeber wrote in a note on Tuesday.

This article appeared in the South China Morning Post print edition as: mistrust deepens with Yuan drop
Post