Advertisement
LifestyleArts

Asian documentary filmmakers worry about the human cost of their work

Documentaries may bring about social and political changes in Asia but filmmakers worry their subjects maybe negatively affected by the exposure

5-MIN READ5-MIN
A still from the documentary The Act of Killing by Joshua Oppenheimer.
Mathew Scott

Indian filmmaker Balaka Ghosh seems to be summing up the predicament faced by so many documentary makers in Asia when she says it wasn't so much the making of her most recent production that gave her sleepless nights, but the thought of the impact its release might have on its subjects once she had packed up her cameras and gone.

"You point your camera at these people, and in many cases, they open up to you and let you into their lives," she says. "But the worry for us - particularly in Asia - is what we leave behind when the film is screened. We are often dealing with such sensitive subjects and cultures that can often be quite secretive. What will the film's impact be on these people who have been so generous with their time? How will it affect their standing in their own society and the people they have to deal with every day?"

Ghosh has been making documentaries out of her base in Calcutta for the past 20 years and her latest production, Footprints in the Desert from 2013, is a prime example of not only the diversity of subject matter being explored across the genre in Asia, but also the lengths these filmmakers sometimes go to get their projects made and the problems they face while doing so.

Advertisement
A scene from The Truth Shall Not Sink With Sewol about the ferry disaster in South Korea, directed by Lee Sang-ho and Ahn Hae-ryong.
A scene from The Truth Shall Not Sink With Sewol about the ferry disaster in South Korea, directed by Lee Sang-ho and Ahn Hae-ryong.

Her film trains its focus on the communities divided by the demarcation line that splits the sand in Rajasthan and was brought in following the second world war to separate India and Pakistan. Nation-building and security formed the bigger picture of that event, but in the details, families and simple traditions that dated back thousands of years were disrupted and in many cases destroyed.

Advertisement

Ghosh wanted the very personal stories of those involved to be revealed. To do that, she first had to spend time with the communities that would form the subject of her film. It ended up being more than five years, off and on.

Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x