-
Advertisement
Asian cinema: Hong Kong film
LifestyleEntertainment

A beginner’s guide to watching Hong Kong martial arts movies, and why realism doesn’t matter

Flying, ‘weightless’ leaps, unrealistic injuries and long fight scenes are all part and parcel of Hong Kong martial arts movies. Here’s why

Reading Time:4 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
1
Jackie Chan in a still from The Young Master (1980). Hong Kong martial arts films blend myth and physical poetry, prioritising style over realism. Photo: Golden Harvest
Richard James Havis

To the uninitiated, the sight of a blood-soaked swordsman fighting on with an arrow lodged in his chest seems absurd. Yet, in the world of Hong Kong cinema, realism is rarely the point.

Martial arts films, whether “kung fu” fisticuffs or “wuxia” sword-fighting, operate on a unique logic of physical poetry and historical myth. Below, to help find your footing, we punch out some commonly held misconceptions about this widely cherished tradition.

Why the unrealistic fights and injuries?

Martial arts films are best enjoyed when viewers understand that the fights are not meant to be realistic. It is a convention of the genre that the protagonists can take more physical punishment than is humanly possible – not least because most real-world fights end within minutes.

Jimmy Wang Yu in a still from Golden Swallow (1968). Photo: Shaw Brothers
Jimmy Wang Yu in a still from Golden Swallow (1968). Photo: Shaw Brothers
Martial arts choreographers such as Sammo Hung Kam-bo extend scenes to showcase combat styles and highlight the performers’ skill and dexterity.
Advertisement
As for the long death scenes, they are imported from the Japanese swordfighting films, chambara, which were very concerned with the concept of dying honourably. The most emotionally draining example of this in a Hong Kong film is without a doubt Chang Cheh’s Golden Swallow (1968).

Is it real kung fu?

The kung fu styles and weapons styles are all based on real martial arts forms, but they are exaggerated, combined and adapted for movie entertainment.

Lau Kar-leung (left) and Gordon Liu in a still from Challenge of the Masters (1976). Photo: Shaw Brothers
Lau Kar-leung (left) and Gordon Liu in a still from Challenge of the Masters (1976). Photo: Shaw Brothers
Advertisement
Select Voice
Select Speed
1.00x