Smartphone with a holographic screen: is Red’s Hydrogen One gimmick or game changer?

  • Display has 3D visuals you can view without special glasses, and offers games and movies converted to the format
  • US$1,295 handset maker’s founder also launched Oakley sunglasses
PUBLISHED : Tuesday, 30 October, 2018, 11:03pm
UPDATED : Thursday, 01 November, 2018, 7:10pm

Most leading phones offer the same basics: big screens, decent battery life and good cameras. So when a newcomer brings something innovative to the party, why is it difficult to break through a phone market dominated by Apple and Samsung?

One such smartphone comes out this week from Red, a company with roots in digital cameras for movie productions. The new Hydrogen One has a holographic screen that produces 3D visuals users can view without special glasses. It is launching with two major movies converted to this format and allows users to create and share their own videos shot with the phone.

Google Pixel 3/Pixel 3 XL: wide-angle selfies, no dual-SIM support

Red’s goals are modest – about 16 million units a year, based on its stated target of 0.5 per cent of Samsung’s sales. But the company will need customers beyond the tech elite and camera buffs; it’ll need their friends and friends of their friends. It does not help that the Hydrogen One carries a hefty US$1,295 price tag.

“The Red Hydrogen One stands little chance of upsetting the smartphone status quo,” said Geoff Blaber, a research analyst at CCS Insight.

Chipping away at Apple’s and Samsung’s dominance is much harder than it used to be because phone innovation isn’t so much about hardware any more, Creative Strategies analyst Carolina Milanesi said. What matters more, she said, is the software and artificial intelligence behind it.

Consider Apple’s new iPhones. Sure, the new XR and XS models all have decent screens, battery life and cameras. But Apple has also been emphasising such software-based features as augmented reality, artificial intelligence and automation using the Siri digital assistant.

It’s important to keep this industry pushing along … and give people some new choice. What we’ve done is pretty nuts
ed founder Jim Jannard

Or take Samsung’s Galaxy Note 9. Its signature features include the use of AI to automatically fine-tune images. While the Hydrogen One’s screen is different, Milanesi said, it’s not necessarily something the mass market will gravitate to. Red founder Jim Jannard said his phone is about making waves in a sea of smartphone sameness.

“We don’t buy the same make, model or colour of car that our next-door neighbour has,” he said. “It’s important to keep this industry pushing along … and give people some new choice. What we’ve done is pretty nuts.”


Jannard has a history of disrupting other industries, too. He previously founded Oakley, which became a force in sunglasses using many of the word-of-mouth techniques he is hoping to replicate with the new phone. The phone starts selling on Friday through AT&T and Verizon in the United States.

Red calls the screen technology 4V, for four view, which is another way of saying it’s doubling what twin-lens 3D cameras produce by adding depth data to each image. There’s a special material under the screen that lets 4V photos and video appear to the viewer in 3D.

Images that aren’t shot or converted to this format will look the same as they do on any other screen. Attempts to photograph a 4V screen will also produce images that don’t look any different.

First look at Huawei Mate 20 Pro – seems like the new phone to beat

The 3D wizardry indeed works, though it’s more pronounced in some scenes than others. Images of a soccer goalie blocking a shot feels realistic, but a waterfall at Yosemite National Park looks like video taken with a regular camera (though leaves in the foreground looked 3D). The Red phone might remind you of holographic stickers in which the view shifts slightly as you tilt them.

Film studio Warner Bros is giving customers of parent company AT&T two free 4V movies: the first Harry Potter prequel, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, and Steven Spielberg’s Ready Player One, which is set in a virtual world.

The studio plans to convert about a half-dozen other movies initially. Red will have tools for producers to convert existing 3D video into the 4V format. The Hydrogen One also has twin lenses in the back to capture 4V photos and video. Trouble is, people you share them with will get a normal image unless they also have a Hydrogen One.

The phone also has a handful of 4V games. Red’s 4V could run into the same problems that virtual reality has faced. People haven’t been rushing out for headsets, while video creators haven’t been rushing out to make virtual reality experiences. There’s a chicken-and-egg problem at play.

Beyond the fancy screen, the phone is thick at a time Apple and Samsung make thinner phones. That is done to fit in a bigger battery, with 12 per cent more capacity than the super-charged Note 9.

The sides have ridges to improve the grip. The phone has pins for expansion modules, such as an adaptor for any standard SLR lens. (Incidentally, a major manufacturer that tried this modularisation approach, LG, backed away from it after a year.)

Five cameras – two for selfies – near-instant GIFs: LG V40 ThinQ stands out

“We’re not trying to win over the whole world,” Jannard said. “We’re trying to provide a phone that we hope enough people like. Otherwise, I’m going to own the single most expensive cellphone in the world, and I’m happy with that.”