avatar image
Advertisement
PostMag
Life.Culture.Discovery.

Then & Now | How the Hong Kong vs Singapore thing got started, and why Lion City doesn’t indulge in such petty comparisons

The perceived rivalry between the two former British colonies has been a media staple for too long – and let’s face it, Singapore has been Asia’s pre-eminent truly cosmopolitan city since way back

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
0
Hong Kong and Singapore – like day and night, some might argue, but it’s a petty debate that’s gone on too long, argues Jason Wordie. Picture: Rebecca Lim

Imagined competition and hyped rivalry between Hong Kong and Singapore have been a media staple for too many years.

During slow news periods, when pages somehow have to be filled, cut-and-paste, compare-and-contrast articles get bashed out with tedious frequency. Content oscil­lates between excoriation of one port city and exaltation of the other, with a few judiciously inserted, deliberately manufactured discussion points to help keep letters pages and online comments busy until some real news comes along.

The skyline of downtown Singapore. Both that country and Hong Kong are compact and heavily built up. Picture: AFP
The skyline of downtown Singapore. Both that country and Hong Kong are compact and heavily built up. Picture: AFP
Victoria Harbour was long the centre of economic activity in Hong Kong, but Singapore’s port had a head start. Picture: Jonathan Wong
Victoria Harbour was long the centre of economic activity in Hong Kong, but Singapore’s port had a head start. Picture: Jonathan Wong

The usual hook for these Hong Kong/Singapore comparisons is some externally bestowed economic accolade one place or the other has been awarded – either for the first time, or for the umpteenth year in weary succession. Or else one or other city has somehow slipped from a previously held benchmark ranking.

Advertisement