Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

How BTS is challenging ‘cutthroat’ K-pop culture by taking a break: the group is defying suffocating fan and industry expectations by prioritising their mental health

BTS. Photo: @bts_bighit/ Twitter
After achieving unprecedented international success for an East Asian act, racking up Grammy nominations, numerous No 1 hits, and generally storming the global pop culture conversation, BTS is taking a much-needed break. “This period of rest will provide the members of BTS, who have tirelessly committed themselves to their activities, a chance to get re-inspired and recharge with creative energy,” the group’s management team, Big Hit, said in a statement on Sunday.
It’s a cutthroat agency .... You’re practically owned by the company … and grow up in such a high pressure, high visibility profession. You’ve also got to perform 24/7 to your fandom – not just the expectation to be available, but also being perfect all the time
Joanna Elfving-Hwang, director, Korea Research Centre, University of Western Australia
V, Suga, Jin, Jungkook, RM, Jimin and J-Hope of BTS arrive at the 2021 American Music Awards at the Microsoft Theatre in Los Angeles, hosted on November 21. Photo: Reuters

“It will also be the first time since their debut for them to spend the holiday season with their families. We kindly ask once again that you show consideration for their need to enjoy ordinary and free everyday lives while solely concentrating on themselves, albeit for a short while, during their period of rest. BTS will be focusing on preparing for the concert and release of the new album that will mark the beginning of a new chapter.”

7 Korean celebrity couples who overcame tough times

Though the news may be disappointing to the band’s notoriously overzealous fan Army, experts say it’s admirable for the group to prioritise their well-being in a culture and industry plagued by mental health taboos. South Korea has one of the highest suicide rates among developed countries, and has seen string of suicides in its music industry, including Shinee’s lead singer Kim Jonghyun and solo star Sulli.
K-pop star Kim Jong-hyun of popular K-pop boy band Shinee bemoaned feeling “broken from inside” and “engulfed” by depression in a suicide note as his death, in 2017, sent shock waves across K-pop fans worldwide. Photo: AFP

“Everyone needs a break, and that is a really powerful message,” says Joanna Elfving-Hwang, an associate professor and director of the Korea Research Centre at the University of Western Australia. “BTS is a global phenomenon, and publicly saying they need time for themselves breaks the mould of the typical image of the K-pop industry, which is 24/7 availability.”

Why is South Korea’s suicide rate so high?

South Korea has one of the highest suicide rates globally among developed nations. Photo: EPA-EFE

Like many East Asian countries, South Korea is known for its highly competitive, individualistic culture, which was largely shaped by its rapid globalisation in recent years.

“The nature of competitiveness in Korea is merciless and relentless,” says Hyeouk Chris Hahm, a professor at Boston University’s School of Social Work. “After being occupied by a military dictator, Korea became much more individualised and egalitarian, and society became very competitive … and as a result, people started experiencing more psychosocial stressors.”

29 Korean stars who tested positive for Covid-19, including Blackpink’s Lisa

A 2016 study found that 30 per cent of South Koreans suffer from mental illnesses. Photo: Shutterstock

This is one of many reasons Korea has one of the highest suicide rates among OECD member nations, she says. A 2016 study found that even though 30 per cent of South Koreans suffer from mental illnesses, only half seek treatment.

“Mental health has traditionally been a taboo subject in South Korea. It’s always been seen as a reflection of character, temperance and maturity,” says Anson Au, a sociologist at the University of Toronto. As a result, stress is normalised as “a part of life that everyone inevitably goes through” and “what results is immense pressure to conform and suppress any mental health issues”.

Members of K-pop boy band Blitzers performing during their dance practice session at a rehearsal studio in Seoul, as part of a rigid training process that keeps young musicians away from their families for months at a time. Photo: AFP

K-pop stars face additional unique challenges. These celebrities are recruited at a young age and often live and train at a company away from their parents.

“It’s a cutthroat agency,” Elfving-Hwang adds. “You’re practically owned by the company … and grow up in such a high pressure, high visibility profession without your family around you. You’ve also got to perform 24/7 to your fandom. You have to be available online, post things constantly and the expectations are huge – not just the expectation to be available, but also being perfect all the time.”

5 K-pop idols whose siblings are as attractive as they are

Is the industry changing or is BTS an exception?

BTS attend a meeting about youth during the 73rd session of the United Nations General Assembly at the United Nations headquarters. Photo: AP

When a group as big as BTS uses their platform to advocate for mental health, it’s inspirational, says Elfving-Hwang.

“It’s a big statement to say ‘we’re going to give ourselves a break’, because they’ve been running like crazy, and it’s important to recognise that anyone should have balance, family time and time for themselves,” she adds.

BTS performing at their Permission to Dance on Stage online concert, one of their final live engagements before announcing a break. Photo: Bright Music

But BTS may have a limited impact on systemic changes for other influencers since the group’s international success “gives them disproportionately more power than any other K-pop performer in the industry”. Most recently, they sold over 200,000 tickets for their December 2 Los Angeles concert – earning the sixth-highest grossing engagement in Billboard Boxscore history.

“People might feel more at ease to talk about their mental health issues now, but that doesn’t take away from the inequality or working culture that created them in the first place. So the stressors may still be there,” Au cautions.

A fan pays tribute to the late K-pop star Goo Hara, who died of suicide in November 2019. Photo: Reuters
Hahm adds that the mental health challenges in the industry are exacerbated for female performers, who face a higher risk of gender violence and sexual harassment. For instance, K-pop star Goo Hara, who died by suicide in 2019, was the subject of tabloid fodder and malicious online messages after a public feud with her ex-boyfriend.

“When men make mistakes, society as a whole is more likely to forgive them. But for women to expose their mistakes, or come out with bold feminist statements or aren’t wearing bras like Sulli (who died by suicide in 2019), then fans will just ostracise them,” Hahm says.

How Song Hye-kyo took the fashion and beauty world by storm

There’s a long road ahead

The BTS boys need a break. Photo: Big Hit Entertainment

“K-pop is a very intense industry and going into it quite young can be extremely hard. That’s why having bands like BTS openly putting out statements saying ‘OK, we need a break’, will hopefully give other production companies and artists permission to focus on their well-being,” Elfving-Hwang says.

If you or someone you know may be struggling with suicidal thoughts, you can call the US National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 800-273-TALK (8255) any time, day or night, or chat online.

Crisis Text Line also provides free, 24/7, confidential support via text message to people in crisis when they dial 741741.

Want more stories like this? Follow STYLE on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and Twitter.
This story originally appeared on USA Today.
  • The suicides of Shinee’s Jonghyun, actress-singer Sulli and Goo Hara drew attention to Korea’s mental health crisis and the immense pressure K-pop stars face
  • While many praise BTS for taking a stance, experts say their international success, and gender, gives them disproportionately more power than other artists