That might sound like hype, but Valenti, who turned 60 in August, has spent the last decade doing everything he can to elevate fashion beyond its status as mere apparel.

In a move that he says was the brainchild of the late art dealer Holly Solomon, Valenti opened up a “fashion gallery” in Miami’s Wynwood neighbourhood in 2011 in an attempt to position his clothes as actual artwork. “We put the clothes on mannequins and sold them as art,” he says. “I told people they can put them in their living room, or put them in Plexiglas on display.”

Eventually, he converted the project into a 501(c)3 (an organisation exempt from US federal income tax under section 501(c)3), which he says was exhausting. In 2015, Valenti bought a house in Joshua Tree, California, intending to move his entire collection to California and start anew.

But in yet another turn of fate, Valenti was contacted by the online retailer Bluefly.com, which asked if he’d be willing to put his entire collection up for sale. “I said, ‘Hey, it’s time to share it with the world’,” he says, and so the sale kicked off this week with an online offering of more than 200 items and an “exhibition” of the clothes at Phillips auction house in New York. If it goes well, he’ll continue selling the remainder of the 20,000 in batches.

“I’m pricing it all to sell,” he says of the clothes, which include a US$695 beige Halston kaftan, a 1980s-era dress by Yves Saint Laurent on sale for US$3,200, and a US$3,500 evening gown by Givenchy. “We’re testing the waters.”

A vintage surge

Coincidentally or not, the sale of Valenti’s collection coincides with a surge in vintage apparel sales. In the past four years, prices per lot in the vintage apparel category have increased by more than 100 per cent, according to data provided by Invaluable.com, the digital platform that represents more than 5,000 brick-and-mortar auction houses.

“From 2014 to 2017, we’ve seen staggering growth in the sale of designer fashions offered on the Invaluable platform,” says Andrew Gully, Invaluable’s director of communications. In that period, total lots offered by auction houses using Invaluable’s platform were up more than 180 per cent, and the total hammer price was up by a stunning 400 per cent.

This year, Gully says, the total hammer is up a further 26 per cent over 2017, and “there are two traditionally high-volume months remaining”.

Investment potential

Valenti, for his part, has a narrower view of the market, given that he’s operating (largely) at the highest end. At that tier, regular buyers have to compete with all of the fashion brands, which are “creating their own museums”, he says.

“And then you have celebrities like Kate Moss. I said [to her]: ‘You have all the money in the world and every designer who will make you clothing; why would you want to wear vintage? What’s wrong with you?’” says Valenti. “And she said, ‘I can’t wear new clothes, because if, for instance, I wear Dior, then the people at Givenchy will hate me. So I’d rather wear vintage.”

Even so, Valenti cautions that the brands that are current are the same as the vintage brands that are doing well. Vintage Balenciaga sells for a lot of money, as does vintage Chanel, and so does vintage Gucci (“This whole Gucci thing is hilarious,” he says of the recent Gucci boom), but vintage Bill Blass doesn’t fare nearly as well. “A Bill Blass suit from the 1980s that I could have sold in the 1990s for US$1,800 will now only command US$1,000,” Valenti says. “No one knows what it is – people forget.”

Extrapolating from that, Valenti says that the investment-potential fashion items deviate based, well, on fashion. “It’s all up and down, depending on the pendulum of fashion,” he says.

For Valenti, all the sales on Bluefly could very well represent a significant return on investment. “I’ve found stuff on dustbins in New York,” he says. “I don’t know if people still do it today, but people would put clothing on top of dustbins for people in need – I found a Balenciaga evening gown in Chelsea that way.”

Valenti also bought in more traditional places – sample sales, from designers’ studios, and so forth – but he seems to relish the truly unusual finds. “I found a Chanel suit under a bridge in Fort Lauderdale, where a bunch of people were selling stuff on blankets,” he says. “You never know.”

Want more stories like this? Sign up here. Follow STYLE on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter