Advertisement

Bright spots seen in Donald Trump and Kim Jong-un’s meeting despite lack of formal accord

  • What has been viewed as a failure in Hanoi could actually provide a stronger foundation for future talks, according to an expert on US-Korea policy
  • ‘We got to a level of detail that has eluded us for quite a while,’ a senior US State Department official said

Reading Time:3 minutes
Why you can trust SCMP
US President Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong-un on Wednesday in Hanoi. Despite the handshake, their summit meeting ended with no formal agreement. Photo: AP

In the wake of US President Donald Trump’s meeting with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un in Hanoi, two US defence and security experts are questioning the perception that the summit was a failure because it ended without a new agreement.

“The history of US-North Korea relations over the past 25 years has been this comic book, black-and-white understanding of history … and this particular summit, which is obviously part of that history, is already being portrayed in a comic book fashion,” Joel Wit, director of 38 North, a website devoted to analysis of North Korea, said on Friday at the New York-based Korea Society.

“Both leaders are heavily invested in this process, and particularly Kim Jong-un,” said Wit, who coordinated implementation of the US-Korea Agreed Framework in 1994 during the presidency of Bill Clinton. That accord collapsed when North Korea was caught enriching uranium.

Advertisement

“His process wasn’t to gather the international media for a photo opp, which a lot of people say. This is a real shift in North Korean policy, and he’s trying to move down a different road,” Wit said. “There was progress made at the summit on a variety of issues, just not enough to reach a final agreement.”

Wit did not provide specifics about what progress was achieved, but his impressions are in line with remarks by a senior US State Department official who said on Friday: “We ended on a very good note between the two sides.”

Advertisement
Advertisement
Select Voice
Choose your listening speed
Get through articles 2x faster
1.25x
250 WPM
Slow
Average
Fast
1.25x