Korean peninsula

After Trump-Kim summit, South Koreans are left wondering: ‘Are we better off than we were a week ago?’

Trump’s announcement about cancelling military exercises seemed to have blindsided officials in Seoul, leaving many South Koreans unsure of how to react

PUBLISHED : Sunday, 17 June, 2018, 9:23am
UPDATED : Sunday, 17 June, 2018, 10:08pm

South Koreans of a certain generation remember a hit children’s animation from 1978, featuring as its hero a Tarzan-like boy who battles an army of North Korean soldiers, depicted as packs of rabid wolves.

By the end of the anti-communist movie, through the courageous feat of the protagonist Ttoli, the corpulent villain Red Marshal, who engorges himself while exploiting his own impoverished people, is unmasked and shown for his true self. As it turns out, the villain – unmistakably modelled after North Korea’s founder, Kim Il-sung – was a pig.

That was then. In recent days, people in South Korea watched as Kim Jong-un, the North’s latest dynastic ruler and the spitting image of Kim Il-sung, his grandfather, appeared to step into a new chapter, styling himself as something of an anti-hero for peace on the Korean peninsula.

Days after Kim’s improbable meeting with President Donald Trump, a first between a sitting US president and a North Korean head of state, South Korea was still parsing the exact ramifications of the summit. The joint agreement signed with much fanfare included no specific or new commitment for the North to relinquish its nuclear weapons, and Trump almost offhandedly announced that military exercises between the United States and South Korea would end, and that he would like to see the eventual withdrawal of 28,000 US troops on the peninsula.

Trump’s announcement about the military exercises seemed to have blindsided officials in Seoul, leaving many South Koreans unsure of how to react to the outcome of the historic summit.

“It’s a first, so I think it’s encouraging. From South Korea’s perspective we’d of course rather they talk than be antagonistic,” said Lee Hye-ran, 35, a campaign manager at a non-profit promoting fair trade. “But there are no specifics on where it goes from here, and the lack of detail is disappointing.”

Kim Jong-un is like a rugby ball. You never know where it’s going to bounce
J.S. Choi, businessman

Lee said Tuesday’s summit between Kim and Trump seemed to be a bigger deal among her friends than the World Cup soccer games that started two days later. Some companies went so far as adjusting work hours so employees could watch the live-stream of the summit.

In the bustling commercial district of Gangnam, made famous by Psy’s 2012 viral hit, it was business as usual this past week, any changes in the potential of nuclear war notwithstanding. Lee said she was tied to her desk, itching to watch history unfold.

South Korean President Moon Jae-in and his defence minister said they would “carefully consider” suspension of the exercises, sparing words in responding to the announcement.

Immediate reactions to the summit were divided along political lines, as they are apt to be in South Korea.

Chosun newspaper, an influential conservative daily, panned the summit, saying it was “the worst outcome for South Korea”.

“Whatever one may think of him, the young North Korean leader has made an incredible achievement simply by getting Trump to meet him,” the paper said in an editorial. “It is simply unbelievable that Trump flew all the way to Singapore to end up with the short end of the stick. This is diplomacy for the kindergarten.”

The liberal Hankyoreh newspaper struck a much more upbeat note, saying Trump and Kim “opened the door to a new era … by taking their first step on the road to peace, a road that has never been taken before”.

The paper did add, though, that the lack of any details or timetable on the actual dismantling of North Korea’s nuclear capabilities was “somewhat unfortunate”.

Donald Trump’s ‘dictator envy’ on full display in latest praise for North Korean leader Kim Jong-un

For his part, Moon, a liberal president who was arguably the major driving force behind the meeting between Trump and Kim, attempted to play up the hopeful voices in his country and discredit the sceptical ones.

“South Koreans are enthusiastically supportive of the outcome of the US-North Korea summit,” Moon told Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Wednesday, according to Moon’s spokesman. “A few experts are giving low marks to the summit results, but that is a far cry from the public sentiment.”

J.S. Choi, a 70-year-old businessman, was among the sceptics. He said he gave little weight to the vague promises of the North Korean leader.

“Kim Jong-un is like a rugby ball. You never know where it’s going to bounce,” said Choi, who runs an import-export company. “We’ve been through this before, we’ve been lied to before. What’s actually been accomplished?”

Choi was flipping through a book on Kim Il-sung at a Gangnam bookstore, where the section on books about North Korea was largely deserted Friday afternoon. Far busier were sections on self-help, employment exams and cryptocurrency.

It is simply unbelievable that Trump flew all the way to Singapore to end up with the short end of the stick. This is diplomacy for the kindergarten
Chosun newspaper

A South Korean soldier in army fatigues on leave from his base in the border region of Cheorwon said he had been too busy with his day-to-day duties to watch the summit or read about it. He said he hadn’t heard about the discontinuation of military exercises, and with six months left in his military service, which is required of all South Korean men, he was preoccupied with looking for a book on the civil service exam.

Choi, though, had read through almost all the hot new books on North Korea. He said what really mattered were the behind-the-scenes working-level talks between Trump’s and Kim’s deputies, the details of which haven’t been made public.

As for the talks, which he watched live from his home in Seoul, he said: “It’s just words. A feast of words. A festival of words.”

Younger South Koreans appeared more eager to do their part to make entreaties across the demilitarised zone separating the two Koreas.

Students at Seoul National University said Friday they sent an email to their counterparts at Pyongyang’s Kim Il-sung University, suggesting they meet in the North Korean capital as soon as this summer. They told reporters they were able to confirm that the email was read, and were anxiously awaiting a reply.

Lee, the non-profit worker, was more tempered in her enthusiasm. She said the meeting between the US and North Korea was significant but said the talks also carried risks of relations deteriorating if they fall through. She said she found it disappointing that Moon appeared to not have been fully looped in.

“But nothing will get resolved if they don’t talk,” she said. “I’m trying to look at it in a positive light.”