appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

TODAY

A Singaporean woman who was found guilty of mistreating two of her domestic workers in her Sentosa Cove residence was on Friday sentenced to 10 months’ jail and ordered to pay compensation to each of the victims.
Tan Lee Hoon, 58, had denied hurting the two workers during a trial that began in December 2020.
She was convicted for seven out of eight charges of voluntarily causing hurt last December and was granted a discharge amounting to an acquittal for the remaining charge.
In sentencing Tan for the seven charges, District Judge Salina Ishak said on Friday that a custodial sentence is usually warranted in cases that involved physical abuse of domestic workers.
Given their vulnerable status, there was a need for public deterrence against abuse by employers towards their domestic workers, she added.
Singapore woman admits to fatally abusing Myanmar domestic helper
Tan’s defence lawyers said in court that she intends to file an appeal against her conviction and sentence.
All eight charges relate to Tan repeatedly assaulting her two Filipino workers, Lizardo Joan Lozares and Jenefer Vegafria Arangote.
The offences took place at Tan’s residence on Paradise Island, which is one of the five man-made islands at Sentosa Cove.
The acquitted charge relates to an alleged incident of Tan hitting Lozares’ torso with a stick sometime in 2018 at the residence.
The court heard that Tan’s abuse of the victims began in September 2018, a month after both Lozares and Vegafria were employed by Tan’s husband Sim Guan Huat.
Although Sim had hired the two victims, it was Tan who primarily managed their day-to-day duties.
Sim was sentenced to five weeks’ jail and an S$8,000 (US$6,090) fine in May 2021 for illegally employing Lozares.

The court previously heard that in one incident, Tan hurt Lozares by kicking her chest while the latter was helping her employer put on her socks and shoes.
In her evidence, Lozares said that Tan was angry with her for putting on the socks wrongly.
Tan was also said to have pinched Vegafria’s chest, stomach, left arm, right bicep and right thigh.
During the trial, it was revealed that Tan had several medical conditions, had difficulty sleeping and needed to be massaged at unusual times of the day because she was “injured”. The court heard that Lozares and Vegafria took turns to do this.
Deputy Public Prosecutor Ng Jun Chong sought a jail sentence of between three months and eight months for each conviction, with a total jail term of between 10 and 13 months.
The prosecutor also sought compensation of S$2,500 (US$1,903) for Lozares and S$5,100 (US$3,864) for Vegafria for their pain and suffering as well as their loss of income.
Singapore woman pleads guilty to blinding Indonesian domestic worker
Tan’s team of defence lawyers, comprising Derek Kang, Ammar Lulla and Ng Sock Cheng from Cairnhill Law, argued that the threshold for a custodial sentence had not been crossed and instead sought a fine of between S$2,000 (US$1,522) and S$7,500 (US$5,709) for each charge.
In the alternative, the defence asked for jail terms as short as one day to about a week for each charge, amounting to one week to two weeks in total.
They also sought to lower the amount of compensation to be given to the victims.
In their submissions, the defence team argued that Tan had no criminal record, was generally of good character and had treated her domestic workers well.
They also submitted character references by about 30 people including Tan’s friends, former domestic workers and other individuals who had witnessed Tan’s interactions with her maids. The references generally vouched for Tan’s good character and how she had treated her household staff members well.
Starved, beaten with hammer: worst domestic worker abuse cases
In her oral remarks, District Judge Salina said that the protection of domestic workers from abuse “is always a matter of public interest”.
This was due to their vulnerable status and the prevalence of employer and domestic worker relationships in Singapore.
Stressing that all these workers must be “treated fairly with dignity and respect”, the judge said that a custodial sentence was “almost invariably warranted” in cases that involve physical abuse.
District Judge Salina said she agreed with the prosecution’s position that there was physical and psychological harm inflicted on the two victims.
For example, with respect to Lozares, the judge found that there was psychological harm in view of the “sustained pattern of abuse”.
For instance, although Vegafria had worked for Tan for about three months, she was physically abused on at least five occasions.
Singapore woman jailed for 30 years for torturing, killing domestic worker
District Judge Salina said that the victim was afraid of reporting the abuse to the authorities because she feared being sent home to the Philippines and being blacklisted from working in the city state.
The judge further agreed with the prosecution’s position that the working conditions for both victims were “oppressive and exploitative”. She cited examples of how Tan had imposed long working hours, docked salaries when she was not satisfied with their work, and did not give the victims enough time to eat, among others.
Tan was handed jail terms of between three months and six months for each charge with two of the sentences to be served consecutively, adding up to a total jail term of 10 months.
Tan will also have to compensate Lozares and Vegafria with S$2,500 and S$5,100 respectively, in line with what the prosecution sought.
Anyone found guilty of voluntarily causing hurt can be punished with a jail term of up to three years or fined up to S$5,000, or both.
In cases where the offences involve a domestic worker, the court may sentence the offender to one-and-a-half times the amount of punishment to which the person would otherwise have been liable for that offence.
This article was first published on Today Online


The evolution of Hong Kong’s independent common law

How Southeast Asia’s ambitious green transition strategy is a windfall for China

Terminal 2 relaunch a global aviation hub milestone for Hong Kong

What to watch at Shangri-La Dialogue after Trump’s China visit resets ties

Singapore

Singapore woman jailed for ‘exploiting’, abusing 2 Filipino domestic helpers

Domestic workers enjoy their day off in Singapore. File photo: SCMP

Domestic helpers enjoying a picnic at a park in Singapore. File photo: AFP

Treatment of Kenyan domestic workers in Hong Kong in spotlight amid reports of trafficking

Meryl, a domestic worker from Kenya in Hong Kong. Photo: Handout

It is illegal to work in a place other than the address in the employment contract, but Meryl said she had no choice. Photo: Handout

Migrant workers line up at a Covid-19 testing centre in Hong Kong. There are 330,000 foreign domestic workers in the city. File photo: AP 

Meryl is pinning her hopes on the processing of a new work visa, which would allow her to work for another employer. Photo: Handout

Singapore woman jailed for 30 years for torturing, killing domestic worker

Gaiyathiri Murugayan (centre), is escorted from her flat in 2016 after the death of her 24-year-old Myanmar domestic helper Piang Ngaih Don. Photo: Today Online

=== PHOTO CAPTURED ONLINE=== Piang Ngaih Don. Photo: Helping Hands for Migrant Workers, Singapore/Facebook

Starved, beaten with hammer, forced to sleep with dog: worst domestic worker abuse cases of Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaysia

Suyanti Sutrinso. Photo: The Straits Times

Candle light vigil for Adelina and all the victims of human trafficking at Patterson Street in Causeway Bay. Late Adelina Lisao, a domestic worker in Malaysia, was reportedly tortured by her employer. 25FEB18 SCMP / Dickson Lee

ALTERNATE CROP OF XKL801 - In this Feb. 10, 2018 photo, Indonesian house maid Adelina Lisao sits on the porch in Bukit Mertajam, near Penang, Malaysia. The Indonesian maid who allegedly suffered injuries on her body and was forced to sleep outside on a porch with a family's dog has died in Malaysia, prompting calls by activists and lawmakers for better laws to safeguard migrant workers. (AP Photo/Por Cheng Han)

Law Wan-tung, former employer of Indonesian domestic helper Erwiana Sulistyaningsih, is escorted by a staff member from Hong Kong Correctional Services inside a van outside the District Court in Wan Chai. Law Wan-tung, 44, was found guilty of 18 of 20 charges of assault, including two counts of inflicting grievous bodily harm on Erwiana Sulistyaningsih. 10FEB15

Former domestic helper Erwiana Sulistyaningsih meets the media at Kowloon Union Church. Erwiana's former employer (who was jailed for causing Erwiana's injuries) was ordered by the District Court to pay her more than HK$8000,000. 22DEC17 SCMP / Nora Tam

Eight arrested after Indonesian authorities bust four human-trafficking syndicates that lured 1,200 victims to work as domestic workers

Suspects enter the press conference room in Jakarta. Photo: AFP

Suspects face the wall during a press conference by Indonesian officials in Jakarta, on April 9, 2019, about trafficking-related offences. - Indonesian police said they had arrested seven people linked to human trafficking cases involving more than 1,000 victims smuggled to the Middle East and North Africa. (Photo by BAY ISMOYO / AFP)

News

Asia

Southeast Asia

Tan Lee Hoon was sentenced to 10 months’ jail and ordered to pay compensation to the victims whom she had kicked and pinched in the chest
Tan, who also imposed long working hours and did not give the women enough time to eat, intends to appeal her conviction


Tan Lee Hoon was sentenced to 10 months’ jail and ordered to pay compensation to the victims whom she had kicked and pinched in the chest.


Crime

The Philippines