Singapore’s Shanmugam rebuts ‘sneering’ Economist article on Lawrence Wong’s political succession

Shanmugam said The Economist could not resist ‘sneering’ at Singapore and the British commentariat class cannot stand seeing the island nation ‘doing better’
The publication said deputy PM Lawrence Wong was ‘guaranteed’ a majority envied by other country leaders amid coming elections, despite not being the first choice

Singapore

TODAY

Published: 9:18pm, 19 Apr 2024

Why you can trust SCMP

Law and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam on Friday criticised a commentary by British publication The Economist, which he said could not “resist sneering” at Singapore’s political leadership handover.

The weekly newspaper’s commentary, published on Thursday, noted that Singapore has had “only” three leaders in its 59 years, and that the next prime minister Lawrence Wong “remains relatively unknown among Singaporeans”.

“He was not the 4G’s [fourth generation leaders’] first choice,” said the publication, noting that Deputy Prime Minister Heng Swee Keat had withdrawn himself from contention for the premiership in 2021.

Despite this, the piece argued, the ruling People’s Action Party (PAP) will win at the coming General Election due to its “formidable organisation, unrelenting attacks on the opposition, a docile press”, among other factors.

They can’t stand that a people they were accustomed to lecturing are now doing better than they are, across the board

K Shanmugam, Singapore’s Law and Home Affairs Minister

In a response published on Facebook on Friday, Shanmugam said the publication “can’t resist” sneering at Singapore due to an instinct lodged “in the unconscious of the British commentariat class”.

Britain was Singapore’s colonial ruler for over a century.

“They can’t stand that a people they were accustomed to lecturing are now doing better than they are, across the board,” said Shanmugam, before outlining areas in which he said the nation has progressed further than Britain.

While Wong, who is Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister, is due to take over from Lee Hsien Loong as the fourth prime minister here in 59 years on May 15, Britain’s Rishi Sunak is the fourth PM in 4.9 years, he said.

Singapore’s Minister for Home Affairs and Law K Shanmugam was not happy about a recent article published by the Economist, criticising the country’s political succession plan. Photo: SCMPOST

During a turbulent period of British politics in the wake of the Brexit vote, Sunak was preceded by Liz Truss, who lasted only a couple of months. She had replaced Boris Johnson, who followed Theresa May.

In economic terms, Singapore’s per capita gross domestic product stands at over S$109,000 (US$80,000) and is the fifth highest by purchasing power parity terms, “well ahead of the UK”, Shanmugam added.

Regarding the media, he retorted: “[The Economist] obviously prefers a situation like in the UK, where one person can control major media outlets, and have politicians pay court to him, and where media owners can influence who gets elected, and who becomes PM.”

Who is Singapore’s Lawrence Wong? From political underdog to next PM

Shanmugam said that Singapore provides “far better healthcare, housing and education” to its people, regardless of classes and races.

The Republic also fares better in terms of public safety and in social cohesion, he added.

Shanmugam highlighted how, for example, 85 per cent of all crime cases reported across England and Wales were closed without any suspect caught while in over 100 neighbourhoods “0 per cent” of reported car thefts were solved. England and Wales are part of Britain.

Singapore’s Wong and China’s Li agree to boost ‘mutually beneficial cooperation’

This is a situation that would be “unthinkable and unacceptable” in Singapore, said the minister.

Shanmugam also cited how a political donor in Britain recently made a racist comment with no consequence, while someone in Singapore is likely to be charged in court for spouting similar comments.

“What price your sneer?” he asked.

The Economist’s 740-word piece called Wong a “compromise candidate” who was not the first choice among the 4G leaders. It added that he was a “highly competent former technocrat”.

02:42

Singapore’s Lee Hsien Loong will hand over power to deputy Lawrence Wong on May 15

Nonetheless, it argued, Wong at the coming polls, is “guaranteed a majority to make the leaders of many other countries weep”.

In spite of the high chances of winning for him and the party, the piece said that “more is at stake” at the coming election.

“At stake for Mr Wong, when he goes to the country, is not his [and the 4G’s] formal mandate but rather moral legitimacy,” it said.

This is in view of how many younger Singaporeans no longer judge the party on its “traditional emphasis of delivering economic growth”, but instead demand “more fairness” in growth and “more participatory” politics, it argued.

Singapore Minister of Finance and Deputy Prime Minister Lawrence Wong will take over for incumbent Lee Hsien Loong on May 15. Photo: Pool/AFP

Commenting on how continuity is to be expected in spite of the leadership change, The Economist article highlighted “at least one key member of the old guard”, Shanmugam, will remain in the Cabinet.

The piece opined that Wong, a “guitar-strumming, confessed nerd brought up on an East Coast housing estate”, is more relatable to Singaporeans “than most of the governing elites”, and starts off with a degree of goodwill.

Singapore’s first social media PM: can Lawrence Wong win Gen Z votes?

However, the coming polls will be his key test.

“If the opposition gets many more than the 10 out of 87 elected seats it currently holds, the change candidate will start off on the back foot,” it wrote.

TODAY has reached out to The Economist for comment.

This article was originally published by Today Online