Advertisement
Advertisement
Argentina
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Javier Milei, Argentina’s president-elect, pauses while addressing supporters at his campaign headquarters in Buenos Aires on Sunday. Photo: AP

New Argentine leader, China critic Javier Milei unlikely to dial back bilateral ties: analysts

  • Far-right former TV pundit campaigned on severing relations with Beijing, but he won with backing from ex-president who warned against doing so
  • China, alarmed by rhetoric, says no country can cut diplomatic ties and ‘still be able to engage in economic trade and cooperation’
Argentina
Argentina’s president-elect Javier Milei will find it difficult to revisit agreements with China that Buenos Aires has already signed and would likely face resistance from close political allies if he tried, analysts have told the Post.
The self-proclaimed anarcho-capitalist Milei campaigned on severing relations with China, one of the South American country’s main trading partners, referring to the government in Beijing as “assassins” and accusing China’s Communist Party of killing those “who cannot do what they want”.

Yet Milei drew vital backing from the centre-right Republican Proposal party (PRO) led by ex-Argentine president Mauricio Macri, who conditioned its support on Milei upholding “the significance of the relationship with China” and warning of “potential risks” if ties with Beijing were severed, according to Bernabé Malacalza of Argentina’s National Scientific and Technical Research Council.

Macri masterminded the candidacy of the PRO’s Patricia Bullrich, who placed third in the first round of the presidential election in October, garnering about 24 per cent of votes.

Javier Milei, presidential candidate of the Liberty Advances coalition, speaks at his campaign headquarters after polls closed for Argentina’s general elections in Buenos Aires on Wednesday. Photo: AP
In the run-off election that Milei won on Sunday, the far-right former television pundit was able to secure votes from many who had cast ballots for Bullrich.

But his Liberty Advances coalition won only 39 of the lower house’s 257 seats and eight of the Senate’s 72 seats, suggesting he would not be able to govern without the support of Macri and his backers.

After Milei’s victory, Diana Mondino, one of his top aides, told Russian news agency RIA Novosti that Argentina would forsake its application to Brics, an association of leading emerging markets comprising Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa.

Mondino, a leading contender to serve as Milei’s foreign minister, said Buenos Aires “will stop cooperating with the governments of Brazil and China” once Milei takes office in December.

Bigger Brics bloc helps China but also brings fresh risks: analysts

The statements alarmed Beijing. China’s foreign ministry on Monday congratulated the Argentine president-elect, but cautioned against breaking commercial and diplomatic agreements that have already been signed.

Mao Ning, a Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman, said Beijing had “always attached great importance to the development of relations” with Argentina and that their ties had come from a “general consensus among all areas of society, with tangible benefits for both peoples”.

“No country can break off diplomatic relations and still be able to engage in economic trade and cooperation,” Mao added. “It would be a huge foreign-policy mistake for Argentina to cut ties with major countries like China or Brazil.”

Beijing voiced its concerns after advisers close to Milei vowed to review agreements the Argentine government already signed or negotiated with the Asian giant. The most important of these involves Espacio Lejano Station in Patagonia in southern Argentina.

China invested US$50 million in the space station’s construction, making it the first structure of its kind to be built outside Chinese territory.

China invested US$50 million to build a space station in Patagonia in southern Argentina. Photo: Reuters

The investment was made possible in 2012 when Argentina approved a land concession to the Chinese government for the project for 50 years.

Beijing has said the station exists solely for scientific pursuits, but concerns about this assertion have been raised since 2018, following Argentine media reports of Chinese military personnel being spotted on site. The project has also generated criticism over a lack of domestic oversight.

Malacalza said Milei would probably face resistance were he to halt space station plans as they relate to China because the agreement was approved by the Argentine Congress.

The same could be said of Argentina’s currency-swap agreements with China. Buenos Aires has been relying on the financial contracts to meet its financial obligations owing to its depleted international reserves and lack of US dollars.

Argentina to open consulate in southwest China to meet ‘growing demands’

In August, Sergio Massa, the country’s economy minister who lost to Milei in the run-off election, announced that the People’s Bank of China released US$1.7 billion in yuan as part of a currency-swap agreement.
At the time, the transfer was essential for Argentina to pay off part of its debt to the International Monetary Fund and avoid another default. Terms of the deal signed with Beijing were kept confidential.

“Swaps are crucial for Argentina. In the short term, replacing this key assistance for reserves is challenging,” added Malacalza, saying the viability of yuan-swap agreements would depend on whether Milei makes good on his controversial campaign pledge of abandoning the Argentine peso as the national currency in favour of the US dollar.

In addition, negotiations for future China-financed projects “may face some challenges”, Malacalza noted.

Sergio Massa, Argentina’s economy minister, seen giving a campaign speech in Buenos Aires on Sunday, lost the run-off election to Javier Milei, who will be the country’s next president for four years from December. Photo: Xinhua

Among the main projects reported to be under negotiation are the construction of a new nuclear power plant in Lima, a small town in Buenos Aires province, and a new port in Rio Grande, a strategic region in Argentina.

Mondino said she intended to offer the projects to private competitors from other countries despite negotiations with China having reached an advanced stage.

Even if Milei softens his tough talk on China, he could still tackle contentious bilateral issues that he thinks need addressing, said Patricio Giusto of the Sino-Argentine Observatory.

Giusto pointed to Argentina’s unfavourable trade deficit, estimated at US$9.5 billion in 2022 alone, as well as several investments that have been paralysed due to the country’s inability to pay its debts.

Although Milei’s victory potentially represents a slowing of Chinese initiatives in the country, his wish to engage the US and European countries in further dialogue might elicit a lukewarm reception from them.

New tilt for Maldives: toward China, away from US’s Indo-Pacific ally India

US President Joe Biden, for instance, waited almost three days after Milei’s victory before speaking with him. When Biden did, he repeated language used by the US State Department, urging the president-elect to focus on issues like sustainability, human rights and climate change.

Milei has previously said he does not consider these issues important.

The US Democratic Party had been “terrified” by the possibility of a Milei victory given his open admiration for Donald Trump and because his candidacy signalled that right-wing sympathies as seen in Brazil and the US were still alive in the region, said Giusto.

Milei’s scant experience in public affairs also fuelled fears among many in the US and Europe, he added. Milei has only been a member of the lower house for two years and has never held a position in Argentina’s executive branch.

“Of course, it is probably more favourable for them to have a president like him who is openly anti-China,” said Giusto, referring to Washington and Brussels.

But in light of “Argentina’s critical situation, this could cause further serious problems”, he added, saying diminished economic relations with Beijing could cause more instability, which would be anything but favourable for the West.

28