Advertisement
Advertisement
Hong Kong protests
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Thousands of people in Hong Kong joined hands on August 23 to create their version of the Baltic Way. Photo: Dickson Lee

Hong Kong protest is not the new Baltic Way, Lithuanian ambassador to China says

  • In 1989, the people of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined hands to regain their ‘statehood’, not just more rights, Ina Marciulionyte says
  • Vilnius ‘adheres with one-China policy, acknowledging that Hong Kong is a legal part of China’, she says
A senior diplomat in Lithuania said she supported peaceful protests in Hong Kong but that those involved should not liken their situation to the “Baltic Way” event that took place three decades ago and helped bring about independence from the Soviet Union for three of its constituent states.

“It is important not to misinterpret the meaning of the Baltic Way in the context of Hong Kong events,” Ina Marciulionyte, Lithuania’s ambassador to China, said in a written interview.

“For the Baltic states it was an act of free will of our societies and peaceful resistance against the foreign occupier Soviet Union which occupied our states before and after the Second World War,” she said.

“The ‘Hong Kong Way’ depicts the will of Hong Kong people to claim more rights within their own law, but not statehood.”
The Baltic Way was formed on August 23, 1989 by the people of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania. Photo: Wikipedia

On August 23, 1989 about 2 million people in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania joined hands to create the Baltic Way – a human chain that stretched 675km (420 miles) across the three republics. In recent weeks, some protesters in Hong Kong have taken to forming similar chains as a sign of their defiance to the city government.

Marciulionyte said that representatives from Lithuania and other European nations had repeatedly told Beijing that peaceful protests and assembly were an integral part of universal human rights, but that did not mean the city was facing the same struggles as the Baltic nations had.

“Lithuania fully adheres with the one-China policy, acknowledging that Hong Kong is a legal part of China,” she said.

“What connects the two ‘ways’ is not the goal, but the means – peaceful resistance. And while it is very important to us, we cannot claim to have invented it, it has been used in history all over the world before.”

On August 23, people in Vilnius recreated their human chain to mark the 30th anniversary of the event and show support for the protesters in Hong Kong. Photo: AFP

On the day the Hong Kong Way was created on August 23, people in the Lithuanian capital Vilnius also joined hands in a show of solidarity and to mark the 30th anniversary of their protest.

The actions in modern-day Vilnius sparked a diplomatic row when local politicians accused China’s ambassador to Lithuania, Shen Zhifei, of directing counter demonstrations against those supporting Hong Kong. He was subsequently summoned by the Lithuanian government to answer to the charges.

“It was this same theme that we raised in conversation with the Chinese diplomats in Vilnius,” Marciulionyte said. “Be they pro-Hong Kong protest supporters or other Chinese nationals, all of them are equal members of the Chinese community living in Lithuania and must respect the right to peaceful demonstrations which is sacred to the people of our country.”

The envoy appealed for urgent steps to be taken to de-escalate the situation in Hong Kong and called for restraint on all sides.

“Violence is not good for anyone,” she said.

But the protests and fighting go on. The latest large-scale human chain was formed on September 14, when thousands of Hongkongers linked hands along Lion Rock, a granite peak overlooking the Kowloon peninsula. The event coincided with the Lantern Festival and participants held lights, unfurled banners and chanted slogans calling for “freedom” for the city and universal suffrage.

The protesters in Hong Kong have also adopted the use of “Lennon Walls” to make their point. These public displays of colourful notes were first seen in Prague in December 1980 after the murder of John Lennon but evolved into a forum for protest in then communist-ruled Czechoslovakia.

China’s state media was quick to put down the ambitions of the Hong Kong Way. In an opinion piece on August 23, People’s Daily said: “Everyone knows what the ‘Baltic Way’ of 30 years ago is … as for the nature of the so-called Hong Kong Way, it is perfectly clear without saying it.

“Where does the Hong Kong Way lead? It will not, and cannot go down the way of ‘Hong Kong independence’. Building human chains to make the so called ‘Hong Kong Way’ is tantamount to digging one’s own grave,” it said.

Protesters in Hong Kong formed a human chain along Lion Rock on September 14. Photo: Winson Wong

Zhang Jianrong, an expert on Russia at the Shanghai Institute of Social Sciences, said the Hong Kong protest was very different to the struggle for independence in the Baltic.

“I wonder how many young people who took part in Hong Kong Way know the history of the Baltic Way,” he said.

“At the time [of the Baltic Way], the Soviet economy was in trouble,” said Zhang. “The people who took part in the Hong Kong Way did so for all sorts of reasons, but most of them were not really thinking about independence.”

Zheng Yifan, a Beijing historian who specialises in the Soviet Union, agreed.

“Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were independent nations before the USSR’s occupation,” he said. “So their demonstration was calling for independence. It is totally different from Hong Kong.”

Richard Turscanyi, a researcher at the Central European Institute of Asian Studies at Palacky University Olomouc in the Czech Republic, said the end of the Soviet Union was a huge shock to China, and Central and Eastern European nations were seen as “traitors” of communism.

“The collapse of the Soviet Union obviously is seen as the major case study to be studied and avoided at all costs,” he said.

“I think the Chinese leadership took an unambiguous lesson from it – no concessions and no wavering.”

Additional reporting by Kinling Lo and Echo Xie

This article appeared in the South China Morning Post print edition as: City protests a far cry from Baltic Way, envoy says
Post