Exclusive | China-EU annual summit ‘pushed back until next year’ as trade and human rights disputes fester

Sources say tit-for-tat sanctions over Xinjiang and the ‘death’ of an investment deal mean there is little room for the two sides to make progress in key areas
The European side is also concerned that President Xi Jinping will not take part and Premier Li Keqiang will host the event instead

China-EU relations

Kinling Loin Beijing,Jun Maiin BeijingandFinbarr Berminghamin Brussels

Published: 11:00pm, 16 Dec 2021

Why you can trust SCMP

The annual EU-China summit has been postponed amid concerns that there is little chance of making progress in key areas, sources said.

One person who has been briefed on the matter said the summit – initially planned to be held by the end of the year – was likely to be put back until January.

Sources identified disagreements over human rights, economics and trade as the biggest sticking points.

The bloc’s relationship with China has been worsening since China responded to EU sanctions on officials accused of human rights abuses in Xinjiang with tit-for-tat measures.

03:36

Beijing hits back at Western sanctions against China’s alleged treatment of Uygur Muslims

This in turn resulted in efforts to ratify the EU-China Comprehensive Agreement on Investment (CAI) – agreed last December – being stalled.

While Beijing was still keen for a meeting to take place before the end of the year, the EU is concerned that President Xi Jinping may not take part and that Beijing will be represented instead by Premier Li Keqiang, whose influence is perceived to be waning ahead of his expected retirement next year.

The last bilateral summit was held virtually in June last year and planned dialogues on trade and human rights have since been further put back.

EU lawmakers raise alarm on Chinese ‘interference in Europe’

“The CAI is already dead. It won’t be surprising if there’s no economic dialogue,” said one European official who added “there is nothing to celebrate”.

The Chinese government has not commented on when the summit will take place.

EU leaders are still weighing whether to diplomatically boycott Beijing’s Winter Olympics, following similar announcements by the US, Australia, Britain and Canada.

Brussels has also backed Lithuania in its dispute with China after it angered Beijing by allowing Taiwan to open a representative office in Vilnius.

Žygimantas Pavilionis (left), head of the Lithunanian legislature’s foreign affairs committee, and Lithuanian lawmaker Emanuelis Zingeris (right) congratulate Eric Huang, head of Taiwanese Representative Office in Lithuania, on the opening of the de facto embassy in Vilnius. Photo: Finbarr Bermingham

Beijing, which regards the island as part of its own territory, responded by downgrading the Lithuanian embassy and, on Wednesday, the Baltic state pulled all its diplomats out of China, citing safety concerns and problems securing accreditation.

On Thursday, Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin hit out at Lithuania for breaching the one-China policy.

“For this the Chinese side has downgraded bilateral diplomatic relations to that of the charge d’affaires … and demanded that our two sides change the titles of their offices to that purpose,” Wang said, adding it was a “sheer fabrication out of nothing” that Lithuania had to recall its diplomats due to security concerns.

China’s Wang Yi warns European nations not to develop ties with Taiwan

The EU has repeatedly said that Lithuania had not breached the one-China policy.

Wang said it had long been a policy of the mainland authorities to ensure the safety and security of all foreign diplomats, and that Lithuania had never complained about the safety of its envoys on the mainland.

Adding further to the tension earlier this month, the EU decided to renew its sanctions on Chinese officials accused of human rights abuses in Xinjiang for a further year.

Lithuanian diplomats have been withdrawn from China, citing safety concerns. Photo: Reuters

Brussels first sanctioned four officials and one entity in Xinjiang – following similar moves from Britain, Canada and the United States in March – the bloc’s first sanctions targeting Chinese officials since the bloody Tiananmen Square crackdown in 1989.

China’s response – targeting European diplomats, officials, academics and politicians – prompted the European Parliament to suspend ratification of the investment deal until they are removed.

Ding Chun, director of the Centre for European Studies at Shanghai’s Fudan University, said a postponement of the summit was no surprise under the circumstances.

EU lawmakers to visit Taiwan next week to meet with Taipei officials

“However, if it is just a delay and not a complete stalling of the talks then it depends on which side has a stronger urge and makes it a higher priority to push forward the summit,” he said.

Ding also said that having Li host the talks rather than Xi had been the “protocol” for years. “I don’t see how this is related to the current tensions,” he added.