China-Vatican relations
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
The Vatican and Beijing have been in talks this year that could lead to a resumption in diplomatic relations after 70 years. Photo: AFP

Hong Kong cardinal calls for Vatican’s top diplomat to resign over China rapprochement talks

Cardinal Joseph Zen says Secretary of State Pietro Parolin should quit over ‘incredible betrayal’

A Hong Kong cardinal who has spearheaded opposition to the Vatican’s rapprochement with Beijing on Thursday called for the Pope’s secretary of state to step down, saying any deal with mainland China would amount to a betrayal of the Catholic faith.

The Vatican and Beijing have been in advanced talks this year to forge what would be a historic breakthrough and precursor to a resumption in diplomatic relations after 70 years, with Secretary of State Pietro Parolin among the chief negotiators.

The Vatican may send a delegation to China before the end of this month. If the meeting goes well, the two could reach an agreement on the appointment of bishops, a Chinese state-run newspaper reported earlier this week.

Vatican deals with China are leaving Catholics around the world baffled

Cardinal Joseph Zen, the most senior Catholic cleric on Chinese soil, said he believed the two sides were making a “secret deal”, although he acknowledged he had no connection with the Vatican and was “completely in the dark”.

“They’re giving the flock into the mouths of the wolves. It’s an incredible betrayal,” he said.

He described Parolin, the highest ranking diplomat in the Vatican, as someone who despised heroes of faith.


“He should resign,” Zen said at his home on a wooded hillside on Hong Kong Island.

“I don’t think he has faith. He is just a good diplomat in a very secular, mundane meaning.”

Zen, who at times knocked his knuckles on the table to make a point, stopped short of calling on Pope Francis to step down, saying: “I would not come out to fight the Holy Father, that is my bottom line.”

The Vatican did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Zen’s remarks.

Betrayed and abandoned: why China’s underground Catholics feel like Jesus on Good Friday

At a time when the Vatican is also under pressure for purportedly covering up a sex abuse scandal in the United States, with one archbishop even calling for the Pope to resign, Zen suggested the China deal would further add to the church’s vulnerability.

“The consequences will be tragic and long lasting, not only for the church in China but for the whole church because it damages the credibility. Maybe that’s why they might keep the agreement secret.”


China’s roughly 12 million Catholics are split between an underground church that swears loyalty to the Vatican, and the state-supervised Catholic Patriotic Association.

The potential deal has divided communities of Catholics across the country, some of whom fear greater suppression should the Vatican cede greater control to Beijing, but others want to see rapprochement.


Zen said he believed only half the underground church in China would accept a deal and was concerned how the remainder might react.

“I’m afraid they may do something irrational, they may make rebellion,” said 86-year-old Zen, a former bishop of Hong Kong and the most outspoken critic of the Pope’s China strategy.

The decline and fall of Chinese Buddhism: how modern politics and fast money corrupted an ancient religion

Pope Francis has rejected criticism that the Holy See may be selling out Catholics to Beijing’s communist government.


Zen said he believed any deal with atheist China would deal a significant blow to Pope Francis’ credibility.

“It’s a complete surrender. It’s a betrayal [of our faith]. I have no other words, he said.