bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

articlePageQuery

filter

article

articleBaseAdvertisingInfoArticle

articleListArticle

articleSeoArticle

hooksArticleAcknowledgementGateOverlayArticle

hooksTrackPageViewArticle

hooksContentInterestArticle

articleLinkingDataContent

hooksAmpRedirectArticle

articleSchemaContent

liveArticle

advertZone

sentiment

contentLock

topics

types

sections

paywallTypes

createdDate

publishedDate

sponsorType

urlAlias

moreOnThisArticles

commentCount

authorLocations

authors

corrections

displaySlideShow

multimediaEmbed

printHeadline

seriesContainer

articleSpeeches

socialHeadline

headline

images

flag

firstTopic

glossary

flattenTypeIds

image

relatedLinks

relatedNewsletters

__typename

sponsor

pdfFiles

seriesReverseOrder

series

disableOffPlatformContent

published

updatedDate

summary

subHeadline

body

keywords

readingTime

customTimezone

liveContents

Sylvie Zhuang

In less than a week, China conducted a series of executions on a scale rarely seen in recent decades.
In all, 16 core members of mafia-like crime syndicates were put to death for a range of crimes, from murder to fraud and human trafficking.
While all of the victims in the cases were Chinese nationals, many of the condemned were citizens of Myanmar, a largely Buddhist country not known for executing crime bosses.
Yet, China was able to convince authorities in Myanmar to hand over suspects.
Observers said Southeast Asian countries might have little choice but to acquiesce, with China showing “merciless resolve” to protect the interests of its citizens abroad.

Bai Yingcang was one of the Myanmese citizens executed earlier this month.
He was a core member of the notorious Bai family, a syndicate at the centre of a massive telecoms scam and illegal gambling operation in Myanmar’s border region of Kokang.
The group’s activities led to the death of six Chinese citizens but, in a televised confession broadcast by CCTV, Bai apologised for harm to many more.
“I would like to represent my entire family, to apologise for the citizens of China and the Chinese government,” he said in footage aired by the Chinese state broadcaster.
“Because of our family’s actions, we have caused harm to tens of thousands of Chinese people. I am deeply sorry for what we have done.”
Other Myanmese executed included Ming Guoping, the second-in-command of the Ming family syndicate, and Xu family crime boss Xu Laofa. Members of a fourth family, the Wei syndicate, have been prosecuted but no sentences have been handed down.


Before the military coup in 2021, Myanmar was in practice an abolitionist state in terms of the death penalty.
After 2021, the junta sentenced more than 160 people, including dissidents and pro-democracy activists, to death, according to the Thailand-based Assistance Association for Political Prisoners.
But there are no reports of crime bosses being executed in the country.
However, Chinese criminal law says China can prosecute severe crimes committed by foreigners abroad if the crime targets China or its citizens.
The law has been on the books since 1979 but really came into its own after the Mekong River massacre in 2011.
In that incident, 13 crew on two cargo ships were murdered and their bodies dumped in the river.
Drug lord Naw Kham, a Myanmese national, was later extradited to China and executed by lethal injection in 2013.
Lin Minwang, an international relations scholar at Fudan University, said the news of the massacre that year shocked China and triggered widespread anger, prompting China’s law enforcement agencies to take a much tougher line on crimes against Chinese citizens.
Lin said the recent extraditions and the executions were partly a “display of strength”, with Southeast Asian countries forced to compromise because of the leverage China has over them.
“Put simply, why did Myanmar’s authorities ultimately hand these people over? They had little choice. If they hadn’t, China has various means to apply pressure,” Lin said.
“Its military government is already under significant domestic and international strain and needs support to survive. China is one of its most important backers.
“What is more important is China’s firm determination to enforce the crackdown resolutely, and I think it comes as a big shock to some smaller surrounding countries.”
Lin said that in the past China – particularly some diplomats – tended to be cautious and mindful of other countries’ sensitivities.
“However, this time it is very clear the push comes from the public security authorities, as domestic anger grows stronger,” he said.


The anger has grown over the past decade or so as countless Chinese have fallen prey to cybercrimes in the region, lured over the border by the promise of high-paying jobs, only to be trapped – and sometimes killed – in scam compounds.
Chinese Public Security Minister Wang Xiaohong has repeatedly called for crackdowns on cyberscams, describing the illegal operations as a “global scourge”.
Chinese envoys to Myanmar have also raised the issue.
On a visit to Myanmar in 2023, then foreign minister Qin Gang could not have been clearer.
“Telecom and online fraud gangs have long been entrenched in Myanmar’s border regions, seriously harming the interests of Chinese citizens, and the Chinese public is deeply angered by this,” Qin said.
“The Chinese government attaches great importance to the issue and is determined to crack down on it with firm and forceful measures.”
After the crime bosses were put to death this year, China’s foreign ministry described the executions as marking “significant progress” in the country’s crackdown on online scams, its efforts to protect the interests of Chinese citizens and cross-border law enforcement.


Wang Jiangyu, an international law professor at City University of Hong Kong, said the extraditions were a strong sign of China’s sway in the region.
“The key members of the four big crime families in Myanmar were apprehended by China, undoubtedly demonstrating China’s influence in regional diplomacy and its power in those surrounding countries,” Wang Jiangyu said.
“The local governments did not cooperate willingly – they acted under pressure.”
Lin from Fudan University said that for China the issue was not a question of diplomacy.
“I think this goes beyond conventional diplomatic framing. China as a major power is prioritising domestic interests. In this latest round of actions, the driving considerations appear to be primarily domestic, with diplomatic concerns likely taking a secondary place.”
This is also the case with Cambodia, another hub of billion-dollar cyberscam empires.
In early January, Phnom Penh revoked the Cambodian citizenship of crime boss Chen Zhi and handed him over to China.
Chen is also wanted by the United States and Britain. He was charged by a federal court in New York in October and US$15 billion in his crypto assets were seized.
“[Those cases show China’s] tremendous resolve, the deterrent power of its law, and a merciless approach to handle criminals harming China’s interests overseas,” Wang Jiangyu said.


China executed a series of Myanmese crime bosses. What does it say about its regional influence?

China rallies neighbours against Japan in rare meeting. Will it work?

China plans regulatory change to help C919 jet compete with Airbus and Boeing

China’s C919 to lift off again at Singapore Airshow in bid for Asean sales

China-Asean relations

Bai Yingcang (far left), was one of the core members of the Bai crime family to be executed in China over a range of illegal activity in Myanmar. Photo: Handout

Bai Yingcang was a core member of the Bai family based in the border region of Kokang, Myanmar. Photo: Handout

Cambodian scam victims’ details found inside compound reveal reach of cyber gangs

A Thai solider inspects a workstation inside a scam centre in O’Smach, Cambodia, on Monday. Photo: AP

Scripts for scam dialogues are pasted inside a booth lined with acoustic foam that was used to make scam calls to victims. Photo: Reuters 

A fake Singapore police uniform is seen on a bed inside a dormitory room in the O’Smach scam compound. Photo: Reuters

A room set up to imitate a branch of Orient Commercial Bank, a major bank in Vietnam. Photo: Reuters 

Shattered glass lies on the floor of a dormitory room inside a compound in O’Smach used for scam operations. Photo: Reuters

China moves to boost cybercrime penalties by adding exit ban after sentences

A draft bill announced by China’s public security ministry aims to impose an exit ban on Chinese found guilty of cross-border online crimes for up to three years after serving their sentence. Photo: Shutterstock

China executes 11 core members of Myanmar-based telecoms fraud ring

Members and associates of the Ming family crime ring attend a sentencing hearing at the Wenzhou Intermediate People’s Court in Zhejiang province, China on September 29.

Photo: CCTV

Why China was so keen to get to alleged cybercrime boss Chen Zhi first

Illustration: Henry Wong


Chen Zhi was extradited from Cambodia to China earlier this month. Photo: Handout

China does not recognise cryptocurrencies like bitcoin as legal tender. Image: Shutterstock

News

China

Politics

The condemned headed family syndicates that trapped Chinese abroad in massive scam centres


The condemned headed family syndicates that trapped Chinese abroad in massive scam centres.


Southeast Asia forced-labour scams

China executed a series of Myanmese crime bosses. What does it say about its regional influence?

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}The condemned headed family syndicates that trapped Chinese abroad in massive scam centres

The condemned headed family syndicates that trapped Chinese abroad in massive scam centres